13 Common Mistakes That Happen During Usability Testing
These mistakes and antipatterns can prevent you from getting the most from your usability testing.
Join the DZone community and get the full member experience.Join For Free
The aim of usability testing is very simple: ask participants to test the application, collect quantitative data from the test results and figure out how the application can be improved. Often, testers or observers make certain mistakes that can lead to a critical defect from where recovering the application can be costly and time-consuming. In this article, we will discuss 13 common mistakes that happen during usability testing and should be taken care of.
Lack of Proper Planning
The most important part of usability testing is planning the entire testing phase. Testers often underestimate the importance of user experience testing and either they don’t plan it properly or keep very little time for it. To prevent critical bugs and bad user experience, it is important that proper planning is involved that includes the goal, methods of testing involved, questions that need to be asked and the type of people to conduct testing with.
Misconception About the Goal
Most testers have a misconception for usability testing. They take it as a way of improving the look and feel of the application. Being design-specific, testers fail to realize that usability testing is about how the user feels while using the application, a combination of user experience along with how the application works. The aim of usability testing is to figure out the part of the application where the user gets frustrated, either with design or with functionality.
Testing With the Incorrect Audience
Usability testing is about bringing in the users meant to use the application. To save time, testers often execute usability testing with the help of their friends or co-workers. This causes results that are not properly validated. It is important that proper screening is carried out before selecting the users. If the users are provided by the client, provide them with requirements that clearly states the type of users to choose and the type to avoid.
Testing at The Last Moment
During a project lifecycle, often usability testing is kept for the last. As a result, often, some critical bug is unveiled at the last moment that results in the project delivery getting delayed, leading to the organization’s loss of reputation and profit. Ideally, usability should be carried out along with the development phase so that if any bug is detected, it gets fixed instantaneously.
In many usability testing labs, participants work along with the observers to test the application. These often leads to unnatural behavior, resulting in a negative impact in the testing phase. A better option is to go for a one-way-mirror procedure, where participants are unaware that someone is observing them while they are testing the application.
Participants Should Not Be Interrupted
The objective of usability testing is to gather information from end users and enough time should be provided to them for observing and concluding a result without any interruption. You can guide them, attract their attention to a specific feature if that is really necessary, but the aim should be to let the users explore the product themselves. The best way to do that is to let the user accomplish a task using our product and keeping in mind that the user doesn’t get interrupted while doing so.
Conducting Only One Usability Testing Phase
Usability testing becomes effective when more than one testing phase is conducted during the development phase. When the test is conducted after the design phase is completed and some major bug is found, it requires a lot of rework to fix the bug. Hence, in every project, at least two testing phases should be conducted, one during the development, and the other when development is over.
The Pilot Test Should Not Be Missed
The pilot test is kind of a rehearsal, where a colleague or a friend plays the role of an end user. The purpose of this test is to figure out potential planning errors and fix them before the testing phase begins. It is important to carry out pilot tests before an end user participates in testing.
Tasks Should be Properly Designed
Designing the tasks have a huge impact on the outcome of test results. Use of proper phrases and guidelines will not only help the participants to effectively execute the testing, but also make the process faster and figure out errors without any difficulty.
Testing Potential Solutions
Although usability testing is great for figuring out errors, it is bad at providing solutions. However, when a problem is detected, designers and developers have multiple solutions ready in hand to fix the problem. It is an important task to choose the best solution to implement that will not impact any other functionality and performance of the application or increase the load of the system.
Proper Behavior with The Facilitator
Facilitators have a great deal of tasks at hand. Apart from communicating with the participants, they are also required to note observations and decide when and what questions to ask. Stakeholders sometimes add more tasks on their shoulder which leads them to get bored and lose patience, thereby missing some critical defects. Treat your facilitator like a normal human being. Assign a few resources to help them and never overburden them with more work.
Treating the Participants Properly
Observers often argue with the participants when they do not agree or have a different opinion about their observations. Participants are a critical part of usability testing and observers should keep and open mind and listen to whatever points they are speaking before jumping to any conclusion.
Premature Test Conclusion
Observers often take note of one or two participants and conclude the testing phase. They should keep an open mind and avoid premature conclusions. Observe a few more participants and note down the patterns. In that way, you will notice many unforeseen issues that may have been ignored before.
Besides proper planning and execution, there are many ways by which usability testing can go wrong. It is ideal to plan and execute the testing phase properly and learn from your earlier mistakes before test phase execution.
Related Post: What Is Usability Testing And Why You Need It?
Published at DZone with permission of Arnab Roy. See the original article here.
Opinions expressed by DZone contributors are their own.