Can the Diversity Problem in Tech Conferences Be Solved?
Can the Diversity Problem in Tech Conferences Be Solved?
2017 is arguably the year the technology industry was most heavily scrutinized for a lack of diversity in the workplace. But what about in conferences?
Join the DZone community and get the full member experience.Join For Free
See why over 50,000 companies trust Jira Software to plan, track, release, and report great software faster than ever before. Try the #1 software development tool used by agile teams.
It’s a well-heard lament in tech. Visit any tech conference somewhere in the world and you’ll be faced with rooms full of white men aged 25-40, with women, people of color, and other diversity factors being sadly underrepresented. As a tech journo, I attend many such events, and besides the marketing team and sometimes conference organizers, I can be one of few women. But it’s easy to complain about this and harder to change things. So, I want to take a look a critical look at the problem as well as some of the great ways this problem is being addressed around the world.
I’d like to start by saying that my intention here is not putting the problems solely on men’s shoulders. The responsibility of diversity falls on conference organizers in that it includes the choice of venue, conference structure, how the conference is marketed, and how and which people are chosen as speakers. Further, I’d like to acknowledge that I’m using the term diversity to represent a big cornucopia of personal identities, abilities, and life experiences that aren’t always visible or disclosed. But I’ll do my best to talk about some specific problems I notice at conferences and offer some examples of solutions.
The Problem With Conference Speakers
The reality of white men dominating speaker spots at conferences is a rightfully vexing one. A recent case in point is that of Serverless Conference in New York. The panel was praised by conference organizers on Twitter for its great lineup, only for people on social media to later point out that it was all men. It’s not the worst example: the reality is that a female speaker was due to be on the panel but was delayed in her travels so an extra person was asked to step in based on who was in the near vicinity of the stage. As someone who has organized events, I can appreciate the scenario. It’s stressful.
In an ideal world, the organizers and panelists to do a quick brainstorm about if they knew someone more diverse than them that could take their palace.
Then there’s the controversy from earlier this year when Luvvie Ajayi to was invited to speak at The Next Web conference in Amsterdam. She asked about a speaker's fee to be told that there was no budget for speakers, only for her to find that others had been offered paid speaking spots.
Boris Veldhuijzen van Zanten, Founder & CEO, The Next Web responded to a query by Forbes saying in part:
“When we reply saying 'we don’t have a budget for speakers’, the whole unpleasant truth is that we need to prioritize whom we spend our limited budget on, and in this case, it’s speakers that are perhaps more relevant for our audience, more sought-after.”
It makes me wonder why big-note speakers are considered the essential cachet of a successful conference. There are a number of men in enterprise I’ve seen deliver the same speech at several conferences around Europe this year. What if that space was offered to a new person with something new to say? Further, when you move into more corporate conferences, the reality is that many conference keynote speakers pay to speak via their company sponsoring the event.
Recommendation 1: Support New Blood
Conferences should encourage first timers to apply rather than asking the same people back every year. If the conference becomes a cocoon of regulars self-congratulating themselves, it’s hardly offering disruption or a change to the status quo.
People from diverse backgrounds should be offered support in preparing their call for proposals (CFP), the gateway to conference speaking. For example, Saturday, February 3rd, 2018 is Global Diversity CFP Day, when there will be numerous workshops hosted around the globe encouraging and advising newbie speakers to put together their very first talk proposal and share their own individual perspective on any subject of interest to people in tech.
Coraline Ada Ehmke, Principal Engineer at Stitch Fix shared:
“Ashe Dryden’s AlterConf project created some of the most diverse speaker lineups that I have ever seen. She accomplished this by reaching out to marginalized people and encouraging them to speak. An important part of why this worked was that she created a sense of safety, by clearly articulating the core values that AlterConf represented, and enforcing those values.”
Recommendation 2: Make Barriers to Entry Easier
There are a number of ways conference organisers can make conference attendance easier. These include:
Reducing the price of or offering free tickets for underrepresented groups. Lisbon’s Web Summit, for example, offers 14,000 free tickets for women for this year’s conference (a practice that not all women support).
Offering equity scholarships where people in financial disadvantage can be reimbursed for accommodation and travel expenses. If this is not possible, billeting is a great option—we’ve hosted some great conference speakers and attendees here in Germany.
Offering childcare. The reality is that people in tech are getting older and having kids. Offering childcare is a great way to increase participation.
Considering access requirements: Is the building wheelchair accessible? Are there different seating options (getting in and out of a bean bag can be hell for many)? Many conferences have dark rooms and lots of steps making them inaccessible to some. I went to a conference recently that included a games room, great fun for some but complete sensory overload when walking through, and given that you had to walk through it every time you needed to pee, it would be a turn off for some!
Recommendation 3: Move Outside the Norm
One way to get speakers outside the usual group speaking is to think about ways a conference might share knowledge beyond the lecture theatre scenario. Conference organizers should be open to a range of speaking scenarios. These might include talks via skype, workshops, walking sessions or whatever else you can think of.
I spoke to Coraline who agreed:
“Lecture-style presentations can be intimidating, so I would like to see more panel discussions and workshops. I believe that giving marginalized people a variety of ways to participate and lead would bring about greater involvement from people in those communities.”
I saw a fascinating talk in Belgrade by Žarko Milenković about the use of VR to enable remote conference attendance. It looked a bit like Second Life, conference-style. Imagine if you could participate in conferences anywhere in the world while still in your hometown. Wouldn't that certainly open up some barriers to entry?
Recommendation 4: Make Diversity Everyone’s Responsibility
Conferences will only change if the attendees demand it. I spoke to a number of men and women in writing this who preferred to remain anonymous. Two men said that when they got to a financial position that they could afford it, they declined their speaker’s fees and requested that they be allocated to fund attendees that were underrepresented.
I also spoke to people who said they refused to attend conferences without a certain percentage of women speaking, making this reason clear to conference organizers.
I’d also suggest that those who think they can help should help. Offering feedback is one thing but offering help is another. Conferences can also help by inviting diverse groups to their events. A lot of conferences could do a better job in expressing the benefits of attending, especially for women and those who may have to save up some cash.
Recommendation 5: Have a Code of Conduct
Does the conference have a code of conduct? A code of conduct is not dissimilar to a workplace policy and Ashe Dryden offers a great example of how it all works with lots of options for further reading. I spoke to conference attendees that will only attend conferences with one of these in place.
Recommendation 6: Consider That Your Incentives May Not Entice Everyone.
Free beer is great unless you can’t drink it and you’re sitting there buying your own drinks. Free swag is great unless the t-shirts don’t fit.
I often wonder why so many tech conferences put time and money into organizing after-parties at mega nightclubs where loud music makes it tough to network. Its time consuming, expensive and a bit pointless considering attendees have to be at the event the next day for morning sessions.
Instead of organizing mega events, one option is to encourage attendees or speakers to organize dinners or smaller gatherings before or during the event through social media such using a Twitter hashtag or the event app. I saw this done to great effect at a documentation breakfast at a local café during Fosdem. Before you spend the conference sponsorship on an event that may not appeal, ask attendees what might be interesting to them.
Resources to Take a Look At:
CallbackWomen aims to radically expand gender diversity at the podium of professional programmers’ conferences.
Ramp-Up provide resources and promotion for event organizations to make inclusive and accessible events.
Diversity Charter is an open charter for event organizers and others to commit to, with resources including sample emails to send to event organizers to encourage diverse speaker representation.
Opinions expressed by DZone contributors are their own.