Over a million developers have joined DZone.

Cross Validation for Kernel Density Estimation

DZone's Guide to

Cross Validation for Kernel Density Estimation

· Big Data Zone ·
Free Resource

Access NoSQL and Big Data through SQL using standard drivers (ODBC, JDBC, ADO.NET). Free Download 

In a post published in July, I mentioned the so-called Goldilocks principle, in the context of kernel density estimation, and bandwidth selection. The bandwidth should not be too small (the variance would be too large) and it should not be too large (the bias would be too large). Another standard method to select the bandwidth, as mentioned this afternoon in class is the cross-validation technique (described in Chiu (1991)). Here, we would like to minimize


The integral can be written


Since the third component is constant, we have to minimize the expected value of the sum of the first two.

The idea is to approximate it as


which can easily be computed. Consider here some sample, with 50 observations, from a Gaussian distribution,

> set.seed(1)
> X=rnorm(50)

From Silverman’s rule of thumb (which should be appropriate here since the sample has a Gaussian sample) the optimal bandwidth is

> 1.06*sd(X)*length(X)^(-1/5)
[1] 0.4030127

Using the cross-validation technique mentioned above, compute

> J=function(h){
+ fhat=Vectorize(function(x) density(X,from=x,to=x,n=1,bw=h)$y)
+ fhati=Vectorize(function(i) density(X[-i],from=X[i],to=X[i],n=1,bw=h)$y)
+ F=fhati(1:length(X))
+ return(integrate(function(x) fhat(x)^2,-Inf,Inf)$value-2*mean(F))
+ }
> vx=seq(.1,1,by=.01)
> vy=Vectorize(J)(vx)
> df=data.frame(vx,vy)
> library(ggplot2)
> qplot(vx,vy,geom="line",data=df)

The function has the following shape

and the optimal value is

> optimize(J,interval=c(.1,1))
[1] 0.4687553

[1] -0.3355477

Note that, indeed, it is close to Siverman’s optimal bandwidth.

The fastest databases need the fastest drivers - learn how you can leverage CData Drivers for high performance NoSQL & Big Data Access.


Published at DZone with permission of

Opinions expressed by DZone contributors are their own.

{{ parent.title || parent.header.title}}

{{ parent.tldr }}

{{ parent.urlSource.name }}