Over a million developers have joined DZone.

EC Threats Pry Microsoft Clam Open

DZone's Guide to

EC Threats Pry Microsoft Clam Open

· ·
Free Resource
In a landmark move, Microsoft is attempting to exorcize the interoperability bogeymen that have haunted it since it was first discovered to be using secret APIs 20 years ago, bogeymen that now quote European antitrust law at it and carry writs from the Court of First Instance in Luxembourg.

The last thing Microsoft needs right now – when it’s practically got Yahoo on its plate – is further confrontation with the European Commission, which opened a broad investigation of Microsoft’s interoperability last month – focused particularly on Office, the .NET Framework and the Office Open XML (OOXML) file format – so the company said it would voluntarily open up all the APIs and communications protocols in its biggest revenue producers now and forever.

To be clear in case there’s a trick meaning here, it said it would open up the APIs and protocols “used by other Microsoft products.”

The decision applies to Vista, Windows Server 2008, SQL Server 2008, Office 2007, Exchange Server 2007, Office SharePoint Server 2007, the .NET Framework and future versions of what it called these “high-volume” products.

Microsoft also promised to document for free the notorious extensions that impact interoperability that it creates when it uses industry standards. It said it would license any patents that cover these extensions on reasonable and non-discriminatory terms at “low royalty rates.”

It did not define “low.”

When Microsoft touched on the subject during a conference call it talked in terms of monetization.

Microsoft also accommodated the anti-Microsoft OpenDocument Format (ODF) that’s promising to create an endless row with the EC.

It said it would design new APIs for the Word, Excel and PowerPoint programs in its Office 2007 suite so that third parties could plug in non-Microsoft file formats and use them as defaults when saving documents.

It didn’t say when these new APIs would be ready.

Microsoft did say it would try to work more closely with the open source community by creating both an online Document Interoperability Initiative and a more broad-based Interoperability Forum.

The regulators at the EC reacted immediately to the concessions Microsoft outlined in a press release before it staged a conference call.

They were highly suspicious in a jaded “reheated hash” kind of way.

In the statement they hung on their web site they said, “Today’s announcement follows at least four similar statements by Microsoft in the past on the importance of interoperability.”

The EC also warned that Microsoft may not escape its vengeance if it finds that Microsoft hasn’t been complying with EU antitrust rules on interoperability before now.

“In the course of its ongoing interoperability investigation,” it said, “ the Commission will therefore verify whether Microsoft is complying with EU antitrust rules, whether the principles announced today would end any infringement were they implemented in practices, and whether or not the principles announced today are in fact implemented in practice.”

The Commission made the point that Microsoft’s actions today don’t address the browser tying claims that it’s investigating separately.

Microsoft general counsel Brad Smith described Microsoft’s move as the company’s view of what will be required and refused to address the EU’s statement. It remains to be seen whether it’s enough. Remember, too, the Microsoft will need a regulatory blessing if Yahoo tumbles.

Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer made it quite clear that Microsoft was in no way retracting or modifying its claim that Linux treads on its IP. He also said that being open and flexible and giving people choice were necessary to Microsoft’s long-term success.

Anyway, Microsoft said any API and protocol documentation would be published on its web site available to all and sundry free of any license or royalty fee. The giveaway is not supposed to have an impact on Microsoft’s revenues.

It said it would start immediately with the 30,000 pages of client and server protocol documentation that it was ordered to share with competitors as a result of antitrust actions on both sides of the pond.

Until now it’s been making this IP available under a fee-based trade secret license through the so-called Microsoft Work Group Server Protocol Program (WSPP) and Microsoft Communication Protocol Program (MCPP). That structure has now all been swept away.

Other protocol documentation will take a few months to get up, it said.

Microsoft said it covenants not to sue any open source developer for non-commercial implementation of the protocols. The patent licenses will cover commercial development, an avenue that is also open to enterprises that use implementations from a distributor that doesn’t have a patent license.

Apparently the open source community can expect a stream of invitations to labs, plug fests and chats.



Opinions expressed by DZone contributors are their own.

{{ parent.title || parent.header.title}}

{{ parent.tldr }}

{{ parent.urlSource.name }}