Mobile Advertising at the Expense of Usibility and the Corner Pizzeria.
Join the DZone community and get the full member experience.Join For Free
The “Maps” application on my iPhone used to work great. It pulled up the number of a nearby joint so fast I never bothered to save those numbers to my contacts list.
Then, about a month back, something annoying happened. I’d search for a local joint – say Gino’s East, to order pizza – and my normal search result appeared different.
While I noticed a difference – my restaurant listing is now a “sponsored link” – I didn’t think much of it. Then the call was answered by GrubHub and not Gino’s East. I hung up.
After further inspection, I discovered my around-the-corner pizzeria is now the unassuming red pin next to the big glaring advertisement.
The math here is pretty obvious – had I completed the call. GrubHub takes a cut from my Pizzeria. Google takes ad dollars from GrubHub. Apple, I’m sure, gets some form of compensation.
Now, let’s talk unintended consequences.
What happens if I succumb to mobile advertising Nirvana and click the default GrubHub ad on every search? I was going to order takeout from my Pizzeria anyway. Similarly, I was going to make a reservation at La Gondola on Saturday regardless of a GrubHub ad. The upshot here is that either my local restaurant takes less profit or raises its prices – one of us ultimately pays for it.
Conversely, what happens if I evade the GrubHub ad? I can – and do – click around the ad to ring my local joint directly. It’s only one extra tap. But it’s a precise tap – while cradling a baby, while walking down the sidewalk, while hanging for dear life inside a CTA train.
Perhaps the precedent is more important. I consider “Maps” an application that I paid for when I bought my iPhone. It came preinstalled. I couldn’t remove it if I wanted to. And the phone certainly wasn’t free.
It’s only one extra tap, but this is the first time I’ve been annoyed by – or ever seen – an ad in a preinstalled application on ANY phone I’ve owned. And this isn’t just any advertising. This advertising affects how I use the phone. Personally, I will pay to avoid being assaulted by advertising. That’s one reason I don’t have an Android phone. That’s the major reason I’m selective about my use of Google.
What’s the upshot?
For me, I see a behavior change. One by one, I’ll add local shops and restaurants to my contact list. Hopefully it’ll take Google a couple more years to find its way there.
For mobile usability, this is a loss, as the extra ad dollar is clearly more important than the paying customer – even on an iPhone.
For my local joints, it’s one more national player trying to take a bite out of their pie. That’s also bad for me.
Published at DZone with permission of Peter Schuh, DZone MVB. See the original article here.
Opinions expressed by DZone contributors are their own.