MySQL 8.0 GA: Quality or Not?
MySQL 8.0 GA: Quality or Not?
Unless you're a funky new web company thriving on the latest technology, give Oracle the opportunity to make a few small bug fix releases before adopting MySQL 8.0 GA.
Join the DZone community and get the full member experience.Join For Free
What does Anton Ego — a fictional restaurant critic from the Pixar movie Ratatouille — have to do with MySQL 8.0 GA?
When it comes to being a software critic, a lot.
In many ways, the work of a software critic is easy. We risk very little and thrive on negative criticism, which is fun to read and write.
But what about those who give their many hours of code development and those who have tested such code before release? How about the many people behind the scenes who brought together packaging, documentation, multiple hours of design, marketing, online resources, and more?
And all of that, I might add, is open-source! Free for the world to take, copy, adapt, and even incorporate in full or in part into their own open development!
It is in exactly that area that the team at MySQL shines once again: they have from their humble beginnings build up a colossally powerful database software that handles much of the world's data — and fast.
Used in every area of life — aerospace, defense, education, finances, government, healthcare, pharma, manufacturing, media, retail, telecoms, hospitality, and finally, the web — it truly is a community effort.
My little contribution to this effort is first and foremost to say: Well done! Well done for such an all-in-all huge endeavor. When I tested MySQL 8.0, I experienced something new: an extraordinarily clean bug report screen when I unleashed our bug hunting rats... ahem... I mean tools. This was somewhat unexpected. Usually, new releases are a fun playground even for seasoned QA engineers who look for the latest toy to break.
I have a suspicion that the team at Oracle either uses newly improved bug-finding tools or perhaps they included some of our methods and tools in their setup. In either case, it is, was, and will be welcome.
When the unexpected occurs, a fight-or-flight syndrome happens. I tend to be a fighter, so I upped the battle and managed to find about 30 bugs, with 21 bugs logged already. Quite a few of them are Sig 11's in release builds. Signal 11 exceptions are unexpected crashes, and release builds are the exact same build you would download at dev.mysql.com.
The debug build also had a number of issues, but less than expected, leading me to the conclusions drawn above. Since Oracle engineers marked many of the issues logged as security bugs, I didn't list them here. I'll give Oracle some time to fix them, but I might add them later.
In summary, my personal recommendation is this: Unless you are a funky new web company thriving on the latest technology, give Oracle the opportunity to make a few small point bug fix releases before adopting MySQL 8.0 GA. After that, providing upgrade prerequisites are matched, and that your software application is compatible, go for it and upgrade.
Before that, this is a great time to start checking out the latest and greatest that MySQL 8.0 GA has to offer!
All in all, I like what I saw, and I expect MySQL 8.0 GA to have a bright future.
Signed, a seasoned software critic.
Published at DZone with permission of Roel Van de Paar , DZone MVB. See the original article here.
Opinions expressed by DZone contributors are their own.