PHP vs ASP.NET: How to Choose a Technology for Web Development
In this article, we'll briefly compare the pros and cons of the two technologies to determine which one is the best option for a web project.
Join the DZone community and get the full member experience.Join For Free
When it comes to web development, choosing a technology stack is one of the top priorities. The complexity and cost of development depend on the choice of technologies, as well as the performance and scalability of your future application. According to Datanyze research, PHP and ASP.NET occupy over 60% of the market share, becoming the most popular tools among web developers. In this article, we'll briefly compare the pros and cons of the two technologies to determine which one is the best option for a web project.
A Few Words About PHP
PHP is a programming language that was originally created for web development, so it’s obvious that when someone is going to work with a web project, PHP comes to mind first. It has many open source tools, extensions, and libraries, making it a simple and convenient technology for creating web products. Sites such as WordPress, Facebook, and Youtube are written in PHP. It’s suitable for various web applications and is compatible with various servers. The choice for this technology often falls when the project needs to be scalable. Also, customers are attracted by the lower cost and speed of development, since many ready-made tools can be found in the community.
Yes, PHP has a large community of more than 5 million developers around the world, so the language is actively developing and improving. The fact that PHP is open source helped it gain the largest market share, and even now many web developers start their career with this programming language.
A Few Words About ASP.NET
Unlike PHP, ASP.NET is not actually a programming language, it’s a C# based framework that opens up great opportunities for web development. ASP.NET also has many libraries and developer tools available, making it a great technology for building various types of apps, including dynamic web pages, microservices, REST APIs, and more. However, unlike the free and open-source PHP, ASP.NET is a paid web development platform offered by Microsoft.
One of the main differences between ASP.NET and PHP is the way the code is executed. PHP has interpreted code that needs to be executed every time on the computer, and ASP.NET code is compiled, which makes it faster and more optimized. ASP.NET supports all the required authentication protocols and provides absolute system security. Also, the technology is constantly being improved by Microsoft, and the ASP.NET community is growing every year, although it has not yet reached the scale of PHP.
Major Technical Differences Between PHP and ASP.NET
Even with a quick overview, we can see that PHP and ASP.NET have little in common, but both technologies are actively used in the development of web applications, depending on the goals and requirements of the project. It’s clear that each of the technologies has its history, its fans, and its opponents. We will try to briefly review and compare the main features of PHP and ASP.NET for web development.
Project size. Traditionally PHP is used to create small projects that don’t need complex support. ASP.NET scales easily and is a great option for large projects as it doesn’t lose performance under heavy load. Plus, PHP projects are more difficult to support.
Type of code. As mentioned earlier, ASP.NET and PHP have different types of code, which affect execution speed. ASP.NET has compiled code, which means it runs like machine code and uses the hardware of the system. However, this introduces additional restrictions on the coding and makes it platform-specific. PHP is an interpreted programming language that makes it platform-independent and allows for a variety of dynamic programming techniques. However, we should keep in mind that interpreted code is slower.
Scalability. Both technologies are great at scaling, but offer different ways of doing it. ASP.NET provides vertical scalability, where you increase overall performance by increasing the performance of every element of the system. PHP assumes horizontal scalability, dividing the system into smaller structures that simultaneously perform the same function on different servers. Therefore, before choosing a technology for your web project, you should decide which method is more convenient for you to scale the project in the future.
Security. When it comes to security, ASP.NET has more features built-in, while PHP provides capabilities, but the ultimate security of the system depends entirely on the skill of the developer. Hence, when choosing PHP, you need to be confident in the professionalism of the engineers you are going to work with and closely monitor the security issues of your web application.
Options. Created for web development, PHP provides many tools for creating attractive and user-friendly web pages. This technology is focused on the end-user and is great for creating corporate websites, social portals. ASP.NET, in turn, is about security and functionality, which is why it often becomes the main technology in the development of business websites, where these features are crucial.
Cost. Of course, PHP being open-source wins by this criterion. Using this programming language reduces the cost of the project. In most cases, you don't need to buy additional licenses or tools to develop new features. ASP.NET is a paid platform from Microsoft that requires additional development costs.
Support. PHP has a large developer community, so if you have a problem, you can find many answers right on the Internet. ASP.NET is actively supported by Microsoft. Also, ASP.NET code is easier to support from the technical side thanks to OOP and typing, which means that even if the code is opened by a developer who didn’t participate in the development, it will be easier for him to figure it out than with a PHP project.
PHP or ASP.NET: What to Choose
We can talk endlessly about the advantages and disadvantages of each of the technologies, and to be honest, both PHP and ASP.NET will help you create a great web solution. It's no surprise that PHP and ASP.NET are market leaders. Let's take a final look at the main benefits of the two technologies.
The choice of technology is most influenced by the specifics of your project. If you are looking for a small corporate website, then specialists most likely will recommend PHP, as this language will allow you to complete your project faster and reduce its cost. If you are planning to develop a complex business portal for internal use, which must be 100% secure and efficient, you should choose ASP.NET.
Anyway, before making a final decision, we advise you to consult with a technical specialist who will study your requirements and find out which technology meets them. Whatever you choose, PHP, or ASP.NET you will need an experienced development team that can get the most out of each technology. A programming language or framework is just a tool that helps you get things done. You just need to know how to work with them. That's the whole secret of successful web development. Good luck with your project!
Opinions expressed by DZone contributors are their own.