Over a million developers have joined DZone.

A Strange case of Java Generic and Inheritage Parameter Passing

· Java Zone

Discover how AppDynamics steps in to upgrade your performance game and prevent your enterprise from these top 10 Java performance problems, brought to you in partnership with AppDynamics.

I came a cross some strange Java code and I would like to share it here. Take a look few of classes I have here:

// file: AFoo.java
package atest.deng;
public abstract class AFoo<T> {
}

// file: Foo.java
package atest.deng;
public class Foo extends AFoo<String> {
}

// file: FooProcessor.java
package atest.deng;
public class FooProcessor<T> {
    public void process(Class<AFoo<?>> cls) {
        System.out.println(cls);
    }
}

// file: FooMain.java
package atest.deng;
public class FooMain {
    public static void main(String[] args) {
        new FooProcessor().process(Foo.class);
    }
}


bash> mvn compile
bash> [INFO] BUILD SUCCESS

I tried this with JDK6 + Maven and it compiles without problem. But try to remove the <T> part from FooProcessor and it will fail to compile!

// file: FooProcessor.java
package atest.deng;
public class FooProcessor {
    public void process(Class<AFoo<?>> cls) {
        System.out.println(cls);
    }
}

bash> mvn clean compile
bash> [ERROR] java-demo\src\main\javatest\deng\FooMain.java:[4,26] process(java.lang.Class<atest.deng.AFoo<?>>) in atest.deng.FooProcessor cannot be applied to (java.lang.Class<atest.deng.Foo>)

With the <T> the code won't compile, and yet we are not even using it in this case. How and why <T> affects the method parameters invocation?

Now, we can improve the FooProcessor in this way so that the presence of <T> doesn't have any affect.

package atest.deng;
public class FooProcessor {
    public void process(Class<? extends AFoo<?>> cls) {
        System.out.println(cls);
    }
}

That's a more proper way to write the generic parameter anyway. But despite a better solution, the puzzle is that the original code compiled under the compiler, but only with the <T> presented, and yet it's not used. Wouldn't you consider this as a Java compiler bug?

The Java Zone is brought to you in partnership with AppDynamics. AppDynamics helps you gain the fundamentals behind application performance, and implement best practices so you can proactively analyze and act on performance problems as they arise, and more specifically with your Java applications. Start a Free Trial.

Topics:

Published at DZone with permission of Zemian Deng , DZone MVB .

Opinions expressed by DZone contributors are their own.

{{ parent.title || parent.header.title}}

{{ parent.tldr }}

{{ parent.urlSource.name }}