Three Problems with Agile
Three Problems with Agile
Issues with Agile that have come up after years of it's use and misuse in business environments.
Join the DZone community and get the full member experience.Join For Free
Engineers build business. See why software teams at Atlassian, PayPal, TripAdvisor, Adobe, and more use GitPrime to be more data-driven. Request a demo today.
The essence of Agile is to ramp up communication between team members to an extreme degree. The idea behind this is to minimize the functionality gaps, design misses and rework so often encountered in waterfall development processes, with an end goal of maximizing the output of usable software.
Ramping up communication, however, has its own set of challenges. For starters, here are just three:
#1 Distributed Team Logistics
For a myriad of reasons (cost, morale, retention, etc.), the past ten years have seen more and more companies allow team members to work from home. However, coordinating sprints across dispersed teams is very difficult. There always seems to be someone missing or joining the conference call late and ‘catching-up’. This is causes disruption and irritation.
Now consider that the typical team these days has members spread across the world. The scrum may start at 9am in San Francisco, but it is lunchtime in New York, dinner time in London, and past bedtime in Bangalore. There is really no good compromise in this scenario. No matter what time the scrum starts, some or all of the team will not be happy.
#2 Continuous Sprints
With Agile, the team is always in a “sprint”. Anyone with even basic sports awareness knows that after a sprint there should be a period of rest. However, there is never a “rest week” on an Agile schedule. For some reason it is always just ‘sprint’, ‘sprint’, ‘sprint’. This can lead to burnout and management resentment.
#3 Availability Conflicts
Very often, business requirements and design validation are sourced from actual business users. However, business users actually have a day job. They can’t be in a room in a scrum all the time. If they are only available intermittently, the process starts to fall apart.
With lack of business user input, teams often end up in an intense discussion of a problem, where no one really understands the problem clearly enough to meaningfully discuss it. And this can be yet another source of team friction.
What is the Solution?
It would seem that these problems and others could be solved by technology, but there are surprisingly few (no?) options out there. What would the ideal solution look like?
One thing is for certain… since different team members (e.g. designer versus developer) have different skill sets and needs, any new tools will have to be role specific.
Published at DZone with permission of Jason Hardy-Smith , DZone MVB. See the original article here.
Opinions expressed by DZone contributors are their own.