Why I don’t use spork
The Agile Zone is brought to you in partnership with Hewlett Packard Enterprise. Discover how HP Agile enterprise solutions can help you achieve high predictability and quality in your development processes by knowing the status of your projects at any point in time.
Spork is great. And so is guard and its family of plugins. Early this year I spent a while converting all of my rails projects to use spork, and we even had a team standard tmux setup that ran spork in one of the start-up screens. So every time we saved a file, guard/spork ran some of our specs. We even had growl/notify pop up a little message telling us the result, so we didn’t have to go to the trouble of switching screen to find out. How very efficient!
But now I’ve turned spork off, and here’s why: Spork solves the wrong problem.
We enabled guard/spork because our specs were slow, and during the few months we had spork, those specs became even slower. But we never noticed. Most of the time guard/spork guessed correctly which specs to run, and we became quite good at configuring guard to re-load Rails when critical files changed. So we were reasonably comfortable, and our specs ran quickly most of the time. But our design was getting worse every day.
Slow specs are a sign of too much coupling, and in the case of a Rails app that usually means not enough separation between the domain objects and the adapters. So we’ve stopped running spork, so that we can feel the pain of the 15-second Rails load time, and so that we can feel the pain of all that coupling. And slowly we are making the app’s specs faster. Many spec files now run in under a hundredth of a second, and more will follow as we gradually peel domain code out from the Rails infrastructure. We don’t need to test the Rails components, and we have a very good suite of cucumber features that act as end-to-end integration tests. So our specs should be fast, and only need to tell us that our own objects each do their thing. That’s what we are now working towards, and that’s the pot of gold that spork was hiding from us.