Kotlin Testing With Spock Part 3: Interface Default Method

Kotlin allows you to put method implementation in an interface. The same mechanism can be found in Java interfaces as default methods (and also Groovy or Scala traits). Let's see the difference between the Kotlin and Java default methods in the interface by testing it with Groovy and Spock.

What Do We Want to Test?

We often have an interface for access object from the database. In the domain, they might look similar to this KotlinOrderRepository:

interface KotlinOrderRepository {
    fun save(order: Order)

    fun find(orderId: OrderId): Order?

    fun get(orderId: OrderId): Order =
            find(orderId) ?: throw NotFound()
}

How to Fake it With Groovy?

When we want to use an interface in tests, we can, of course, mock it. However, it is far better to fake repositories with a simple, in-memory implementation. Let's create FakeKotlinOrderRepository in Groovy:

class FakeKotlinOrderRepository implements KotlinOrderRepository {
    private Map<OrderId, Order> data = [:]

    @Override
    void save(Order order) {
        data[order.id] = order
    }

    @Override
    Order find(OrderId orderId) {
        return data[orderId]
    }
}

Unfortunately, this causes a compilation error:

/testing-kotlin-in-spock/src/test/groovy/com/github/alien11689/testingkotlinwithspock/defaultmethod/FakeKotlinOrderRepository.groovy: 3: Can't have an abstract method in a non-abstract class. The class 'com.github.alien11689.testingkotlinwithspock.defaultmethod.FakeKotlinOrderRepository' must be declared abstract or the method 'com.github.alien11689.testingkotlinwithspock.defaultmethod.Order get(com.github.alien11689.testingkotlinwithspock.defaultmethod.OrderId)' must be implemented.
 @ line 3, column 1.
   class FakeKotlinOrderRepository implements KotlinOrderRepository {
   ^

1 error

The compiler doesn't see the implementation of theget method in the Kotlin interface. We have to use some magic to make it work in Groovy.

Solution

To solve the problem, let's look into the generated classes:

$ ls build/classes/main/com/github/alien11689/testingkotlinwithspock/defaultmethod/
JavaOrderRepository.class
KotlinOrderRepository.class
KotlinOrderRepository$DefaultImpls.class
NotFound.class
Order.class
OrderId.class

The KotlinOrderRepository$DefaultImpls class is the one we're looking for as we can use it in Groovy to implement the missing operation.

class FakeKotlinOrderRepository implements KotlinOrderRepository {

    // ...

    Order get(OrderId orderId) {
        return KotlinOrderRepository.DefaultImpls.get(this, orderId)
    }
}

Now, the code compiles and tests pass:

class KotlinRepositoryWithDefaultMethodTest extends Specification {
    OrderId orderId = new OrderId(UUID.randomUUID() as String)
    Order order = new Order(orderId, 'data')
    KotlinOrderRepository kotlinOrderRepository = new FakeKotlinOrderRepository()

    def 'should get order from kotlin repository'() {
        given:
            kotlinOrderRepository.save(order)
        expect:
            kotlinOrderRepository.get(orderId) == order
    }

    def 'should throw NotFound when order does not exist in kotlin repository'() {
        when:
            kotlinOrderRepository.get(orderId)
        then:
            thrown(NotFound)
    }
}

Is There the Same Problem With Java?

Let's have a quick look at how this works with Java interfaces. If we write a similar repository in Java:

public interface JavaOrderRepository {
    void save(Order order);

    Optional<Order> find(OrderId orderId);

    default Order get(OrderId orderId) {
        return find(orderId).orElseThrow(NotFound::new);
    }
}

And create a fake implementation in Groovy:

class FakeJavaOrderRepository implements JavaOrderRepository {
    private Map<OrderId, Order> data = [:]

    @Override
    void save(Order order) {
        data[order.id] = order
    }

    @Override
    Optional<Order> find(OrderId orderId) {
        return Optional.ofNullable(data[orderId])
    }
}

There is no compilation error and the tests pass:

class JavaRepositoryWithDefaultMethodTest extends Specification {
    OrderId orderId = new OrderId(UUID.randomUUID() as String)
    Order order = new Order(orderId, 'data')
    JavaOrderRepository javaOrderRepository = new FakeJavaOrderRepository()

    def 'should get order from java repository'() {
        given:
            javaOrderRepository.save(order)
        expect:
            javaOrderRepository.get(orderId) == order
    }

    def 'should throw NotFound when order does not exist in java repository'() {
        when:
            javaOrderRepository.get(orderId)
        then:
            thrown(NotFound)
    }
}

Groovy can implement Java interfaces with the default methods without any problems.

The source code for this example is available here.