DZone
Thanks for visiting DZone today,
Edit Profile
  • Manage Email Subscriptions
  • How to Post to DZone
  • Article Submission Guidelines
Sign Out View Profile
  • Post an Article
  • Manage My Drafts
Over 2 million developers have joined DZone.
Log In / Join
Refcards Trend Reports
Events Video Library
Over 2 million developers have joined DZone. Join Today! Thanks for visiting DZone today,
Edit Profile Manage Email Subscriptions Moderation Admin Console How to Post to DZone Article Submission Guidelines
View Profile
Sign Out
Refcards
Trend Reports
Events
View Events Video Library
Zones
Culture and Methodologies Agile Career Development Methodologies Team Management
Data Engineering AI/ML Big Data Data Databases IoT
Software Design and Architecture Cloud Architecture Containers Integration Microservices Performance Security
Coding Frameworks Java JavaScript Languages Tools
Testing, Deployment, and Maintenance Deployment DevOps and CI/CD Maintenance Monitoring and Observability Testing, Tools, and Frameworks
Culture and Methodologies
Agile Career Development Methodologies Team Management
Data Engineering
AI/ML Big Data Data Databases IoT
Software Design and Architecture
Cloud Architecture Containers Integration Microservices Performance Security
Coding
Frameworks Java JavaScript Languages Tools
Testing, Deployment, and Maintenance
Deployment DevOps and CI/CD Maintenance Monitoring and Observability Testing, Tools, and Frameworks

Integrating PostgreSQL Databases with ANF: Join this workshop to learn how to create a PostgreSQL server using Instaclustr’s managed service

[DZone Research] Observability + Performance: We want to hear your experience and insights. Join us for our annual survey (enter to win $$).

Monitoring and Observability for LLMs: Datadog and Google Cloud discuss how to achieve optimal AI model performance.

Automated Testing: The latest on architecture, TDD, and the benefits of AI and low-code tools.

Related

  • Why Software Development Leaders Should Invest in Continuous Learning and Growth Opportunities
  • How To Level Up in Your Data Engineering Role
  • Engineering Manager: Resolving Organizational Conflicts
  • Engineering Manager: Resolving Interpersonal Situations

Trending

  • Reflections From a DBA
  • JWT Token Revocation: Centralized Control vs. Distributed Kafka Handling
  • Writing Reusable SQL Queries for Your Application With DbVisualizer Scripts
  • Navigating the Skies
  1. DZone
  2. Culture and Methodologies
  3. Career Development
  4. Performance Reviews Are A Waste of Time

Performance Reviews Are A Waste of Time

Employee performance reviews are fairly pervasive for most jobs, but have you ever asked yourself what is achieved?

Scott Sosna user avatar by
Scott Sosna
CORE ·
Aug. 04, 23 · Opinion
Like (5)
Save
Tweet
Share
5.74K Views

Join the DZone community and get the full member experience.

Join For Free

At least weekly, I am asked for feedback or thoughts on a recent commercial interaction, most obviously for one-time transactions with a company rendering services; e.g., lawn service, gutter cleaning, teeth cleaning, financial, etc. Year over year, these requests increase (prefaced with, "And anything other than 5's is considered a failure...") and you start questioning the value-add. Tipping is a form of review. Returning or repeating customers are definitely a review of the services provided. Is there any actual value?  But I digress. . .

White Collar image

Image Source: "White Collar, c. 1940 - Linocuts by Giacomo G. Patri" by Thomas Shahan 3 is licensed under CC BY 2.0

In the United States, employee performance reviews are fairly de rigueur and pervasive for most jobs, especially for white-collar positions, but have you ever asked yourself what is achieved? Leaders can't wait to discuss ongoing problems if the problems would worsen. Performance improvement plans are often a precursor for firing chronic under-performers (except at Netflix). Career roadmap discussions or changes in career goals need to happen more than once per year.  So what is the intended purpose of an annual performance review?

My manager at my second full-time job started my review with the following statement: 

I have not done my job if you hear anything that we haven't previously discussed.

- Jim D, CSC Consulting manager

I found this incredibly useful and insightful, and often share this with managers and peers: feedback - positive or negative - should be in the moment, relevant, and continual for maximum impact. Of course, that assumes your manager actually tracks your work, which I've discovered is often not the case: multiple managers have asked me to write reviews for their peers! 

Performance reviews, in my opinion, are a perfunctory, HR activity rather than anything useful, and in the last 15 years, I have basically stopped any active participation, just the bare minimum effort to keep my manager out of trouble.

My Turning Point

I completed my first full year at Fortune 50 Company X, and, as expected, the new calendar year starts the performance review cycle. Performance reviews are serious business here: formalized, 360-degree feedback, scored, and time-consuming. If the scuttlebutt is correct, each year the lowest 10% are released to challenge and refresh the employee base.

Personally, I'm not concerned: I've mastered the business domain, I've contributed positively to my project, my team functions at a high level, and I've expanded my reach into other parts of the org.   The wrap-up meeting with my manager confirms this: I am top 10% for my role across the entire organization. Congrats, keep up the good work, we're lucky to have you. Whoo hoo!

At the same time performance reviews wrapped up, project senior leadership changed, and managers meet with the new leaders to introduce themselves, their teams, and their responsibilities - normal stuff.  My manager used the just-completed performance reviews to start the discussion about each person on her team.  When it was time to discuss me, unprompted the new leader stated, "Scott likes to make people feel stupid."

Wha?!?

I had no idea where this comment came from: I had not met or worked with her previously, she hadn't yet been formally introduced, and my initial meet-and-greet was two weeks out. My manager was surprised and also had no idea what her opinion was based on. I was not specifically targeted, and there were others similarly surprised by her opinions.

Regardless, I went from high performer to scum-of-the-earth overnight and realized quickly that image rehabilitation was difficult if not impossible.

And If That's Not Enough...

I've had other experiences that just further enhance my thoughts on the worthlessness of performance reviews.

Mandatory Deflation

After a poor fiscal year, one company instructed leaders to reduce review scores by 10% to reduce the annual bonus payouts. Wrong approach: performance reviews should reflect the quality (or lack thereof) of your work and a way to achieve corporate goals.

Instead, I would have expected a proactive message from the president: 

I know everyone has worked really hard over the last year, and despite your hard work fiscally it's been a rough year. Therefore, I need to let everyone know that bonuses will be smaller than in recent years, for everyone at all levels. You should not take a reduced bonus personally: we must be fiscally responsible to better position ourselves for improvements this year. I know this is tough, but I hope you understand.

Unfortunately, the company was not proactive and instead chose to game the system, frustrating everyone.

Mismatched Role Expectations

One company hired architects as Director Without Reports to ensure competitive salaries and bonus structures for their technology leaders.

Unfortunately, the performance review scoring expected directors to manage direct reports, and therefore architects scored lower compared to other directors because of this. Our manager fought hard and diminished the impact, but it still impacted our raises, end-of-year bonuses, and opportunity for growth.  Despite ongoing discussions, HR seemed incapable of understanding and made no changes to better reflect a reality they didn't grok.

Unnoticed Non-Participation

By now, I was totally jaded on performance reviews and did as little as possible, enough to not cause problems with my manager: complete self-review but don't provide any information; sign the printed review without reading or discussing; click whatever is necessary to move workflow along. I now knew this was to please HR and otherwise a complete waste of time.

More recently, my overall self-review comment was:

I am a penguin, prove me wrong.  

Penguins can't fly, I can't fly therefore I am penguin shirt imageThe first time I was surprised that no one noticed: not my immediate manager, not his director who supposedly reads reviews for all direct and indirect reports, not senior leaders who make salary/bonus decisions based on reviews.  Not a peep, even when I didn't provide any other information.

Leaders knew their team and had preconceived notions: the trusted, the hard workers, the laggards, the losers. No amount of formal performance review process would change that, but HR required the formality and so they went through the motions.

Final Thoughts

Let me be clear: for all the managers who dread performance review season and make the minimal effort required, there are those who view performance reviews as important to employees and make the commensurate effort.

My wife believes her teams deserve reviews that are insightful, thoughtful, and personal, and spends hours on each person. Her meetings with each person look back at achievements - personal, team, organization - and forward-looking at upcoming projects and goals, and is a continuation of the one-on-one meetings held throughout the year. The result: a high-functioning team that understands business challenges, expectations, business, and personal goals.

Perhaps my thoughts on performance reviews would be more positive with strong management earlier in my career, but unfortunately, that didn't happen. Now, in the later stages of my career, I've learned how to get my work done with and without the expected management support.  Is it ideal? No, but it's the reality, and as such performance reviews have fallen off my list of things to trust.

Architect (software) career teams

Published at DZone with permission of . See the original article here.

Opinions expressed by DZone contributors are their own.

Related

  • Why Software Development Leaders Should Invest in Continuous Learning and Growth Opportunities
  • How To Level Up in Your Data Engineering Role
  • Engineering Manager: Resolving Organizational Conflicts
  • Engineering Manager: Resolving Interpersonal Situations

Comments

Partner Resources

X

ABOUT US

  • About DZone
  • Send feedback
  • Careers
  • Sitemap

ADVERTISE

  • Advertise with DZone

CONTRIBUTE ON DZONE

  • Article Submission Guidelines
  • Become a Contributor
  • Visit the Writers' Zone

LEGAL

  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy

CONTACT US

  • 3343 Perimeter Hill Drive
  • Suite 100
  • Nashville, TN 37211
  • support@dzone.com

Let's be friends: