DZone
Thanks for visiting DZone today,
Edit Profile
  • Manage Email Subscriptions
  • How to Post to DZone
  • Article Submission Guidelines
Sign Out View Profile
  • Post an Article
  • Manage My Drafts
Over 2 million developers have joined DZone.
Log In / Join
Refcards Trend Reports
Events Video Library
Refcards
Trend Reports

Events

View Events Video Library

The Latest Software Design and Architecture Topics

article thumbnail
Reporting Back from MongoDB World 2014, NYC, Planet JSON
Closely approaching the one year mark of when I first joined MongoLab (and the MongoDB community), I had the pleasure of attending the inaugural MongoDB World conference put together by the incredible MongoDB team. Second only to the excitement around major MongoDB feature announcements was the collective disbelief that this was MongoDB’s first multi-day conference ever. A big congratulations to all those that worked hard to put on such a massive (did you see the Intrepid!?) event. All this planning would have been for naught if MongoDB leaders and engineers failed to deliver announcements and features that would meet and exceed expectations. From major public cloud announcements to the reveal of document-level locking in version 2.8, developers and conference goers had plenty to be excited about. There was a lot to digest from the conference… we’ll cover the major highlights in case you missed them. Big announcements in public cloud Our time at the MongoLab booth yielded many high-quality conversations, predominantly those about offloading previously internal processes and workloads to the public cloud. It was remarkable to see and hear so many enterprise teams with the exact same message: the public cloud is the future, and the future is now. It’s no surprise then that MongoDB, Inc. released not one, but two press releases around MongoDB solutions for the public cloud. Fully-managed MongoDB on the Microsoft Azure Store Nearly one year ago, MongoDB, Inc. chose to partner with the MongoLab team to build a production-ready MongoDB solution for developers on Microsoft Azure. On the first day of World, MongoDB, Inc. announced the product of our collaboration – a fully-managed highly available MongoDB-as-a-Service Add-On offering on the Microsoft Azure Store. This new service runs MongoDB Enterprise and offers replication, monitoring and support from MongoDB, Inc. It’s also backed by MongoDB Management Service (MMS), allowing for point-in-time recovery of MongoDB deployments. Now, teams without the expertise or resources to manage their MongoDB deployment(s) can outsource all the database operations (monitoring and alerting, backups, performance tuning, etc.) to both MongoLab and MongoDB’s expert support teams. You can check out the MongoDB add-on in the Azure Store: https://azure.microsoft.com/en-us/gallery/store/mongodb/mongodb-inc/ MongoDB solutions on Google Cloud Platform MongoDB, Inc. also announced the arrival of new resources to help Google Cloud Platform customers deploy MongoDB on Google Compute Engine. These resources include a “Click to Deploy” feature and a MongoDB on Google Compute Engine Solutions paper covering MongoDB best practices. If you are looking for a fully-managed solution, with automated provisioning, backups, integrated monitoring and alerting, along with expert support, MongoLab recently announced the arrival of production-ready replica sets on Google. Product Roadmap – MongoDB version 2.8 On the second day of MongoDB World, Eliot Horowitz, MongoDB, Inc. CTO & Co-founder, took center stage and announced two huge changes to the MongoDB core project: document-level locking and pluggable storage engines. These features not only reflect improvements to the core project, but also signal to the community that the MongoDB team is listening to its users and is capable of delivering the software needed to power the workloads of tomorrow. Document-level locking The slides above from Eliot’s keynote point to a current obstacle (database-level locking) in MongoDB that limits overall scalability. With database-level locking, any write operation to the database holds the write lock and prevents subsequent writes from executing on the database until the original operation holding the write lock completes. Eliot’s announcement of document-level locking moves the write lock contention from the database level to the document (MongoDB equivalent to SQL “records”) level. This change will allow users to achieve much higher write throughput (we saw a 10x performance improvement in the live demo) across their MongoDB deployments, improving write scalability. If you’d like to try out document-level locking, the MongoDB team has already pushed the feature to the master branch on GitHub. This should only be used for experimentation, not to be run in production. Pluggable storage engine As MongoDB matures, feature releases like document level locking will continue to allow developers to build robust systems on top of MongoDB. But as the number of use cases grows, different tooling tailored to specific use cases may prove to be extremely beneficial. For example, if Company X decides that they want to use MongoDB to warehouse some of their data, they would likely want to optimize their database for slow-moving data and storage efficiency (compression). With the introduction of pluggable storage engines, many new possibilities are open to the community. Teams can now write their own storage engine for a particular use case, configure replica set nodes with different storage engines for specific situations, or collaborate with the open-source community to architect innovative solutions. This feature not only allows for more granular control of the database, but also encourages the MongoDB community to work together. Takeaways: A maturing and thriving ecosystem Roughly a year ago, MongoLab CTO Todd Dampier recapped MongoSF 2013 and spoke to the health of the MongoDB ecosystem. How far we’ve come! After attending the inaugural MongoDB World and chatting with MongoDB Masters, interns, hackathon winners, power users and those new to the community, the enthusiasm is still surging and as positive as ever. This enthusiasm is well placed. Developers and hackers use MongoDB because so much rich data on the web is shared as JSON (think Facebook, Twitter, Google, etc.). As a result, MongoDB is the de-facto database for hackathons and bootstrapped projects. Just learn the API for the site you want to mine, throw the JSON in MongoDB and query your data with the rich query language- it’s that easy. The MongoDB ecosystem is maturing as well. Take a look at the Customer Success Stories and you’ll get a feel for the extent in which enterprises leverage the solution and use it in production. To further drive enterprise adoption, MongoDB, Inc.’s public cloud solutions and product roadmap features aim to help teams run MongoDB in production and give teams the confidence that MongoDB will continue to improve scalability and meet their growing project requirements. Congratulations again to the MongoDB team on their big announcements and for creating such a fantastic forum at which to learn and meet fellow MongoDB users. Our team at MongoLab had a great time making new friends and talking shop; we look forward to meeting more MongoDB users soon (at a MongoDB Days near you)! -Chris@MongoLab
July 2, 2014
by Chris Chang
· 6,510 Views
article thumbnail
Option.fold() Considered Unreadable
We had a lengthy discussion recently during code review whether scala.Option.fold() is idiomatic and clever or maybe unreadable and tricky? Let's first describe what the problem is. Option.fold does two things: maps a function f overOption's value (if any) or returns an alternative alt if it's absent. Using simple pattern matching we can implement it as follows: val option: Option[T] = //... def alt: R = //... def f(in: T): R = //... val x: R = option match { case Some(v) => f(v) case None => alt } If you prefer one-liner, fold is actually a combination of map and getOrElse val x: R = option map f getOrElse alt Or, if you are a C programmer that still wants to write in C, but using Scala compiler: val x: R = if (option.isDefined) f(option.get) else alt Interestingly this is similar to how fold() is actually implemented, but that's an implementation detail. OK, all of the above can be replaced with single Option.fold(): val x: R = option.fold(alt)(f) Technically you can even use /: and \: operators (alt /: option) - but that would be simply masochistic. I have three problems with option.fold() idiom. First of all - it's anything but readable. We are folding (reducing) over Option - which doesn't really make much sense. Secondly it reverses the ordinary positive-then-negative-case flow by starting with failure (absence, alt) condition followed by presence block (f function; see also: Refactoring map-getOrElse to fold). Interestingly this method would work great for me if it was named mapOrElse: ** * Hypothetical in Option */ def mapOrElse[B](f: A => B, alt: => B): B = this map f getOrElse alt Actually there is already such method in Scalaz, called OptionW.cata. cata. Here is whatMartin Odersky has to say about it: "I personally find methods like cata that take two closures as arguments are often overdoing it. Do you really gain in readability over map + getOrElse? Think of a newcomer to your code[...]"While cata has some theoretical background, Option.fold just sounds like a random name collision that doesn't bring anything to the table, apart from confusion. I know what you'll say, that TraversableOnce has fold and we are sort-of doing the same thing. Why it's a random collision rather than extending the contract described inTraversableOnce? fold() method in Scala collections typically just delegates to one offoldLeft()/foldRight() (the one that works better for given data structure), thus it doesn't guarantee order and folding function has to be associative. But inOption.fold() the contract is different: folding function takes just one parameter rather than two. If you read my previous article about folds you know that reducing function always takes two parameters: current element and accumulated value (initial value during first iteration). But Option.fold() takes just one parameter: current Option value! This breaks the consistency, especially when realizing Option.foldLeft() andOption.foldRight() have correct contract (but it doesn't mean they are more readable). The only way to understand folding over option is to imagine Option as a sequence with0 or 1 elements. Then it sort of makes sense, right? No. def double(x: Int) = x * 2 Some(21).fold(-1)(double) //OK: 42 None.fold(-1)(double) //OK: -1 but: Some(21).toList.fold(-1)(double) : error: type mismatch; found : Int => Int required: (Int, Int) => Int Some(21).toList.fold(-1)(double) ^ If we treat Option[T] as a List[T], awkward Option.fold() breaks because it has different type than TraversableOnce.fold(). This is my biggest concern. I can't understand why folding wasn't defined in terms of the type system (trait?) and implemented strictly. As an example take a look at: Data.Foldable in Haskell (advanced) Data.Foldable typeclass describes various flavours of folding in Haskell. There are familiar foldl/foldr/foldl1/foldr1, in Scala namedfoldLeft/foldRight/reduceLeft/reduceRight accordingly. They have the same type as Scala and behave unsurprisingly with all types that you can fold over, including Maybe, lists, arrays, etc. There is also a function named fold, but it has a completely different meaning: class Foldable t where fold :: Monoid m => t m -> m While other folds are quite complex, this one barely takes a foldable container of ms (which have to be Monoids) and returns the same Monoid type. A quick recap: a type can be aMonoid if there exists a neutral value of that type and an operation that takes two values and produces just one. Applying that function with one of the arguments being neutral value yields the other argument. String ([Char]) is a good example with empty string being neutral value (mempty) and string concatenation being such operation (mappend). Notice that there are two different ways you can construct monoids for numbers: under addition with neutral value being 0 (x + 0 == 0 + x == x for any x) and under multiplication with neutral 1 (x * 1 == 1 * x == x for any x). Let's stick to strings. If I fold empty list of strings, I'll get an empty string. But when a list contains many elements, they are being concatenated: > fold ([] :: [String]) "" > fold [] :: String "" > fold ["foo", "bar"] "foobar" In the first example we have to explicitly say what is the type of empty list []. Otherwise Haskell compiler can't figure out what is the type of elements in a list, thus which monoid instance to choose. In second example we declare that whatever is returned from fold [], it should be a String. From that the compiler infers that [] actually must have a type of [String]. Last fold is the simplest: the program folds over elements in list and concatenates them because concatenation is the operation defined in Monoid Stringtypeclass instance. Back to options (or more precisely Maybe). Folding over Maybe monad having type parameter being Monoid (I can't believe I just said it) has an interesting interpretation: it either returns value inside Maybe or a default Monoid value: > fold (Just "abc") "abc" > fold Nothing :: String "" Just "abc" is same as Some("abc") in Scala. You can see here that if Maybe Stringis Nothing, neutral String monoid value is returned, that is an empty string. Summary Haskell shows that folding (also over Maybe) can be at least consistent. In ScalaOption.fold is unrelated to List.fold, confusing and unreadable. I advise avoiding it and staying with slightly more verbose map/getOrElse transformations or pattern matching. PS: Did I mention there is also Either.fold() (with even different contract) but noTry.fold()?
June 26, 2014
by Tomasz Nurkiewicz
· 9,625 Views
article thumbnail
Eclipse Community Survey 2014 Results
We have published the results of the Eclipse Community Survey 2014. Thank you to everyone who participated in the survey this year. The complete results and data are available for anyone to download [xls] [ods]. As in other years, I think the results provide an interesting perspective on what tools software developers are using and the type of applications they are building. Here are some key highlights from the results this year: 1) Git #1 Code Management Tool. Git has finally surpassed Subversion to be the top code management tool used by software developers. A third of developers (33.3%) report they use Git as their primary code management tool compared to 30.7% using Subversion. Subversion continues to show a downward trend from previous years when it was used by more than half the developers. Of note, 9.6% claim GitHub is their primary code management tool so the prevalence of overall Git usage is becoming dominate. 2) Maven and Jenkins Key Tools. For Build and Release tools, Maven and Jenkins continue to be key tools used by developers. Of interest is the growth of Gradle from 2013 (4.5%) to 2014 (11%). 3) Top 3 Application Servers. Tomcat (32.6%), JBoss (11.8%) and Jetty (7.2%) continue to be the top 3 application servers. 4) Java 8 Adoption. Java 8 was released in March 2014 and already 9.2% of Java developers have migrated to Java 8 as their primary version of Java. 59.2% are using Java 7 but close to a quarter are using Java 6 or before. 5) Majority of Developers Use JavaScript. More and more software developers use multiple languages to develop software. Due to the Eclipse biased of the survey, Java is not surprisingly the top primary language. However, when asked what other languages developers might use, JavaScript stands out to be a popular language with a the majority of developers (56.2%) claiming it as a secondary language. 6) Developers Experimenting With Open Hardware. The Internet of Things (IoT) and Open Hardware have become important industry trends in the last couple of years. Over a third (35.7%) of software developers are spending their own personal time learning about devices like the BeagleBone, Arduino and Raspberry Pi. Thanks again to everyone who participated in the survey. I hope everyone finds the results of interest.
June 25, 2014
by Ian Skerrett
· 14,319 Views
article thumbnail
Software Architecture as Code
if you've been following the blog, you will have seen a couple of posts recently about the alignment of software architecture and code. software architecture vs code talks about the typical gap between how we think about the software architecture vs the code that we write, while an architecturally-evident coding style shows an example of how to ensure that the code does reflect those architectural concepts. the basic summary of the story so far is that things get much easier to understand if your architectural ideas map simply and explicitly into the code. regular readers will also know that i'm a big fan of using diagrams to visualise and communicate the architecture of a software system, and this "big picture" view of the world is often hard to see from the thousands of lines of code that make up our software systems. one of the things that i teach people during my sketching workshops is how to sketch out a software system using a small number of simple diagrams, each at very separate levels of abstraction. this is based upon my c4 model , which you can find an introduction to at simple sketches for diagramming your software architecture . the feedback from people using this model has been great, and many have a follow-up question of "what tooling would you recommend?". my answer has typically been "visio or omnigraffle", but it's obvious that there's an opportunity here. representing the software architecture model in code i've had a lot of different ideas over the past few months for how to create, what is essentially, a lightweight modelling tool and for some reason, all of these ideas came together last week while i was at the goto amsterdam conference. i'm not sure why, but i had a number of conversations that inspired me in different ways, so i skipped one of the talks to throw some code together and test out some ideas. this is basically what i came up with... model model = new model(); softwaresystem techtribes = model.addsoftwaresystem(location.internal, "techtribes.je", "techtribes.je is the only way to keep up to date with the it, tech and digital sector in jersey and guernsey, channel islands"); person anonymoususer = model.addperson(location.external, "anonymous user", "anybody on the web."); person aggregateduser = model.addperson(location.external, "aggregated user", "a user or business with content that is aggregated into the website."); person adminuser = model.addperson(location.external, "administration user", "a system administration user."); anonymoususer.uses(techtribes, "view people, tribes (businesses, communities and interest groups), content, events, jobs, etc from the local tech, digital and it sector."); aggregateduser.uses(techtribes, "manage user profile and tribe membership."); adminuser.uses(techtribes, "add people, add tribes and manage tribe membership."); softwaresystem twitter = model.addsoftwaresystem(location.external, "twitter", "twitter.com"); techtribes.uses(twitter, "gets profile information and tweets from."); softwaresystem github = model.addsoftwaresystem(location.external, "github", "github.com"); techtribes.uses(github, "gets information about public code repositories from."); softwaresystem blogs = model.addsoftwaresystem(location.external, "blogs", "rss and atom feeds"); techtribes.uses(blogs, "gets content using rss and atom feeds from."); container webapplication = techtribes.addcontainer("web application", "allows users to view people, tribes, content, events, jobs, etc from the local tech, digital and it sector.", "apache tomcat 7.x"); container contentupdater = techtribes.addcontainer("content updater", "updates profiles, tweets, github repos and content on a scheduled basis.", "standalone java 7 application"); container relationaldatabase = techtribes.addcontainer("relational database", "stores people, tribes, tribe membership, talks, events, jobs, badges, github repos, etc.", "mysql 5.5.x"); container nosqlstore = techtribes.addcontainer("nosql data store", "stores content from rss/atom feeds (blog posts) and tweets.", "mongodb 2.2.x"); container filesystem = techtribes.addcontainer("file system", "stores search indexes.", null); anonymoususer.uses(webapplication, "view people, tribes (businesses, communities and interest groups), content, events, jobs, etc from the local tech, digital and it sector."); authenticateduser.uses(webapplication, "manage user profile and tribe membership."); adminuser.uses(webapplication, "add people, add tribes and manage tribe membership."); webapplication.uses(relationaldatabase, "reads from and writes data to"); webapplication.uses(nosqlstore, "reads from"); webapplication.uses(filesystem, "reads from"); contentupdater.uses(relationaldatabase, "reads from and writes data to"); contentupdater.uses(nosqlstore, "reads from and writes data to"); contentupdater.uses(filesystem, "writes to"); contentupdater.uses(twitter, "gets profile information and tweets from."); contentupdater.uses(github, "gets information about public code repositories from."); contentupdater.uses(blogs, "gets content using rss and atom feeds from."); it's a description of the context and container levels of my c4 model for the techtribes.je system. hopefully it doesn't need too much explanation if you're familiar with the model, although there are some ways in which the code can be made simpler and more fluent. since this is code though, we can easily constrain the model and version it. this approach works well for the high-level architectural concepts because there are very few of them, plus it's hard to extract this information from the code. but i don't want to start crafting up a large amount of code to describe the components that reside in each container, particularly as there are potentially lots of them and i'm unsure of the exact relationships between them. scanning the codebase for components if your code does reflect your architecture (i.e. you're using an architecturally-evident coding style), the obvious solution is to just scan the codebase for those components, and use those to automatically populate the model. how do we signify what a "component" is? in java, we can use annotations... package je.techtribes.component.tweet; import com.structurizr.annotation.component; ... @component(description = "provides access to tweets.") public interface tweetcomponent { /** * gets the most recent tweets by page number. */ list getrecenttweets(int page, int pagesize); ... } identifying those components is then a matter of scanning the source or the compiled bytecode. i've played around with this idea on and off for a few months, using a combination of java annotations along with annotation processors and libraries including scannotation, javassist and jdepend. the reflections library on google code makes this easy to do, and now i have simple java program that looks for my component annotation on classes in the classpath and automatically adds those to the model. as for the dependencies between components, again this is fairly straightforward to do with reflections. i have a bunch of other annotations too, for example to represent dependencies between a component and a container or software system, but the principle is still the same - the architecturally significant elements and their dependencies can mostly be embedded in the code. creating some views the model itself is useful, but ideally i want to look at that model from different angles, much like the diagrams that i teach people to draw when they attend my sketching workshop. after a little thought about what this means and what each view is constrained to show, i created a simple domain model to represent the context, container and component views... model model = ... softwaresystem techtribes = model.getsoftwaresystemwithname("techtribes.je"); container contentupdater = techtribes.getcontainerwithname("content updater"); // context view contextview contextview = model.createcontextview(techtribes); contextview.addallsoftwaresystems(); contextview.addallpeople(); // container view containerview containerview = model.createcontainerview(techtribes); containerview.addallsoftwaresystems(); containerview.addallpeople(); containerview.addallcontainers(); // component view for the content updater container componentview componentview = model.createcomponentview(techtribes, contentupdater); componentview.addallsoftwaresystems(); componentview.addallcontainers(); componentview.addallcomponents(); // let's exclude the logging component as it's used by everything componentview.remove(contentupdater.getcomponentwithname("loggingcomponent")); componentview.removeelementswithnorelationships(); again, this is all in code so it's quick to create, versionable and very customisable. exporting the model now that i have a model of my software system and a number of views that i'd like to see, i could do with drawing some pictures. i could create a diagramming tool in java that reads the model directly, but perhaps a better approach is to serialize the object model out to an external format so that other tools can use it. and that's what i did, courtesy of the jackson library . the resulting json file is over 600 lines long ( you can see it here ), but don't forget most of this has been generated automatically by java code scanning for components and their dependencies. visualising the views the last question is how to visualise the information contained in the model and there are a number of ways to do this. i'd really like somebody to build a google maps or prezi-style diagramming tool where you can pinch-zoom in and out to see different views of the model, but my ui skills leave something to be desired in that area. for the meantime, i've thrown together a simple diagramming tool using html 5, css and javascript that takes a json string and visualises the views contained within it. my vision here is to create a lightweight model visualisation tool rather than a visio clone where you have to draw everything yourself. i've deployed this app on pivotal web services and you can try it for yourself . you'll have to drag the boxes around to lay out the elements and it's not very pretty, but the concept works. the screenshot that follows shows the techtribes.je context diagram. thoughts? all of the c4 model java code is open source and sitting on github . this is only a few hours of work so far and there are no tests, so think of this as a prototype more than anything else at the moment. i really like the simplicity of capturing a software architecture model in code, and using an architecturally-evident coding style allows you to create large chunks of that model automatically. this also opens up the door to some other opportunities such automated build plugins, lightweight documentation tooling, etc. caveats apply with the applicability of this to all software systems, but i'm excited at the possibilities. thoughts?
June 25, 2014
by Simon Brown
· 9,547 Views
article thumbnail
How to Install Mono on a Raspberry Pi
This post exists to help with an MSDN Magazine article that I am authoring It provides some of the low-level details for the article How to install Mono and root certificates on a raspberry pi How to create an Azure mobile service How to create a Custom API inside Azure mobile services that the raspberry pi can call into How to create an Azure storage account MONO - HOW TO INSTALL ON A RASPBERRY PI Why Mono? How to install Mono on a raspberry pi Installing trusted root certificates on to the raspberry pi http://www.mono-project.com/Main_Page An open source, cross-platform, implementation of C# and the CLR that is binary compatible with Microsoft.NET Mono is a free and open source project led by Xamarin (formerly by Novell) that provides a .NET Framework-compatible set of tools including, among others, a C# compiler and a Common Language Runtime WHY MONO? Because it lets us write .net code compiled on Windows We can simply copy the binary files from Windows to Linux and run it as is From a raspberry pi device, it is possible to use a .net application to take a photo and upload it to Windows Azure storage HOW TO INSTALL ON A RASPBERRY PI RUNNING LINUX You will issue the following commands: pi@raspberrypi ~ $ sudo apt-get update pi@raspberrypi ~ $ sudo apt-get install mono-complete The first command makes sure all the local package index are up to date with the changes made in repositories. Second command installs the complete Mono tooling and runtime. MAKING SURE THAT YOUR MONO APPLICATIONS CAN MAKE A HTTPS REST-BASED CALLS This command downloads the trusted root certificates from the Mozilla LXR web site into the Mono certificate store. Once complete, the Raspberry PI will be capable of making web requests using HTTPS requests within Mono. pi@raspberrypi ~ $ mozroots --import --ask-remove --machine CREATING A NEW AZURE MOBILE SERVICES ACCOUNT The mobile services account is needed to host a Node.js application that provides shared access signatures to raspberry pi devices The shared access signature is needed by the raspberry pi, so that it can directly and securely upload photos to Azure storage STEPS TO CREATE AN AZURE MOBILE SERVICE The steps below will create an Azure mobile service The service will be used to host a Node.js application interacting with a raspberry pi devices We will provision a SQL database, although it will not be used initially FOLLOW THESE STEPS TO CREATE THE MOBILE SERVICE Login into the Azure Portal Select MOBILE SERVICES from the left menu pane at the Azure Portal. In the lower left corner select "+NEW" to create a new Azure Mobile Service. Make sure you've selected, "COMPUTE / MOBILE SERVICE / CREATE." You will now enter a url. We will call this service raspberrymobileservice. For the DATABASE, we will choose "Create a new SQL database instance." The REGION we chose is "West US." The BACKEND is "JavaScript." Click the "->" arrow to proceed to the next screen. In this screen you will "Specify database settings." The NAME of your database will based on the URL you entered previously. In this case, the database is called "raspberrymobileservice_db." You will need to choose a SERVER. We will choose "New SQL database server" from the drop-down list. You will need to provide a SERVER LOGIN NAME and a SERVER LOGIN PASSWORD. Take note of the login you provided as it will be needed later CREATING A CUSTOM API Azure mobile services allows you to create a custom API written in JavaScript that can be called from a raspberry pi device using REST This custom API is really just a Node.js application running in the server CREATING THE API TO RESPOND TO THE DEVICE TRYING TO UPLOAD PHOTOS Now that the service is established, we will turn our attention to creating an API that the device can call into to upload a photo. Login into the Azure Portal Your mobile service will take a few minutes to complete, and you should see the "Ready" flag as the "Status" for your service. Once it is ready you can drill into your service to customize its behavior. Just to the right of the service name, click the right arrow key "->" to drill into the service details. The top menu bar will offer many options, but we are interested in the one titled "API." The API allows you to create a series of node.JS API calls that a device can call into using rest-based approaches. Click on "API." from there, select "CREATE A CUSTOM API." You will be asked to provide an API name. Type in "photos" for the API name. Below you will see a series of drop-down combo boxes that relate to permission. We will keep the default value of "Anybody with the application key." This might not be the best option for all scenarios. You can read more about this here. http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/azure/jj193161.aspx. Click the checkmark to complete the process. The name of the AP you just created, "Photos," should be visible on the portal interface. To drill into the photos API click on the right arrow key "->". The right arrow key will be just to the right of the name of the API "Photos". At this point you should see a basic script that has been provided by default. We will overwrite this default script with our own script as described in the MSDN Magazine article. CREATING A STORAGE ACCOUNT TO STORE THE PHOTOS Navigate to the portal and create a storage account Create a container for the photos Obtain the: Storage Account Name (you will provide a name) Storage Account Access key (generated for you) Container Name (you will create) CREATING A STORAGE ACCOUNT We will need a storage account so that we can upload photos to it. The steps are well documented here: http://azure.microsoft.com/en-us/documentation/articles/storage-create-storage-account/ In our case we call the storage account raspberrystorage. This means that the URL that the device will use to upload photos is https://raspberrystorage.blob.core.windows.net/. As you complete these steps make sure that you choose the storage account location to be the same location as was used for your mobile services account. This avoids any unnecessary latency or bandwidth costs between data centers. Once the storage account is created, we will need to create a container within it. Photos or any blob for that matter, are always stored within a container. To create a container drill into your newly created storage account and select CONTAINERS from the top menu. From there, select CREATE A CONTAINER. The new container dialog box will ask for a name for your container. Take note of the name you provide. We are calling our container ?photocontainer.? When the raspberry pi device uploads photos to the storage account, it will target a specific container, such as the one we just created. You will next be asked to indicate ACCESS rights. To keep things simple we will select access rights of Public Blob. ENTERING APP SETTINGS Rather than hard-code storage account information inside your JavaScript/Node.js applications, you should consider using apps settings inside of the Azure mobile services portal This post also discusses it well: http://blogs.msdn.com/b/carlosfigueira/archive/2013/12/09/application-settings-in-azure-mobile-services.aspx ?The idea of application settings is a set of key-value pairs which can be set for the mobile service (either via the portal or via the command-line interface), and those values could be then read in the service runtime.? NAVIGATING TO APP SETTINGS Navigate to the Azure Mobile Services section of the portal. Drill into the specific service by hitting the arrow below Select from the Configure Menu at the top Scroll down to the very bottom to see app settings Note that we need to enter: - We need to get this from Azure Storage - PhotoContainerName - AccountName - AccountKey We get this information from the Azure Storage Section of the Portal. Note that you need to have provisioned a Storage Account to have this information. How to get the AccountKey with Azure Storage Services Now you can get the access keys HOW NODE.JS WILL ACCESS THE APP SETTINGS You will create a Node.js application inside of Azure Mobile Services See previous steps THE NODE.JS APPLICATION READING APP SETTINGS You will starting by going back to Azure Mobile Services and drill down into your newly minted service We called ours raspberrymobileservice Once you click API, you should see: Notice the app settings are being read on lines 12 to 14.
June 19, 2014
by Bruno Terkaly
· 16,813 Views
article thumbnail
Internet of Things (IoT) Reference Architecture
to converge internet of thing devices with corporate it solutions, teams require a reference architecture for the internet of things (iot). the reference architecture must include devices, server-side capabilities, and cloud architecture required to interact with and manage the devices. a reference architecture should provide architects and developers of iot projects with an effective starting point that addresses major iot project and system requirements. a high-level iot reference architecture may include the following layers (see figure 1): external communications - web/portal, dashboard, apis event processing and analytics (including data storage) aggregation / bus layer – esb and message broker device communications devices cross-‐cutting layers include: device and application management identity and access management a more detailed architecture component description can be found in the iot reference architecture white paper .
June 18, 2014
by Chris Haddad
· 17,825 Views
article thumbnail
Spring Security Misconfiguration
I recently saw Mike Wienser’s SpringOne2GX talk about Application Security Pitfalls. It is very informative and worth watching if you are using Spring’s stack on servlet container. It reminded me one serious Spring Security Misconfiguration I was facing once. Going to explain it on Spring’s Guide Project called Securing a Web Application. This project uses Spring Boot, Spring Integration and Spring MVC. Project uses these views: @Configuration public class MvcConfig extends WebMvcConfigurerAdapter { @Override public void addViewControllers(ViewControllerRegistry registry) { registry.addViewController("/home").setViewName("home"); registry.addViewController("/").setViewName("home"); registry.addViewController("/hello").setViewName("hello"); registry.addViewController("/login").setViewName("login"); } } Where “/home”, “/” and “/login” URLs should be publicly accessible and “/hello” should be accessible only to authenticated user. Here is original Spring Security configuration from Guide: @Configuration @EnableWebMvcSecurity public class WebSecurityConfig extends WebSecurityConfigurerAdapter { @Override protected void configure(HttpSecurity http) throws Exception { http .authorizeRequests() .antMatchers("/", "/home").permitAll() .anyRequest().authenticated(); http .formLogin() .loginPage("/login") .permitAll() .and() .logout() .permitAll(); } @Override protected void configure(AuthenticationManagerBuilder auth) throws Exception { auth .inMemoryAuthentication() .withUser("user").password("password").roles("USER"); } } Nice and explanatory as all Spring’s Guides are. First “configure” method registers “/” and “home” as public and specifies that everything else should be authenticated. It also registers login URL. Second “configure” method specifies authentication method for role “USER”. Of course you don’t want to use it like this in production :). Now I am going to slightly amend this code. @Override protected void configure(HttpSecurity http) throws Exception { //!!! Don't use this example !!! http .authorizeRequests() .antMatchers("/hello").hasRole("USER"); //... same as above ... } Everything is public and private endpoints have to be listed. You can see that my amended code have the same behavior as original. In fact it saved one line of code. But there is serious problem with this. What if my I need to introduce new private endpoint? Let’s say I am not aware of the fact that it needs to be registered in Spring Security configuration. My new endpoint would be public. Such misconfiguration is really hard to catch and can lead to unwanted exposure of URLs. So conclusion is: Always authenticate all endpoints by default.
June 17, 2014
by Lubos Krnac
· 12,088 Views · 1 Like
article thumbnail
Java 8 Friday: 10 Subtle Mistakes When Using the Streams API
at data geekery , we love java. and as we’re really into jooq’s fluent api and query dsl , we’re absolutely thrilled about what java 8 will bring to our ecosystem. java 8 friday every friday, we’re showing you a couple of nice new tutorial-style java 8 features, which take advantage of lambda expressions, extension methods, and other great stuff. you’ll find the source code on github . 10 subtle mistakes when using the streams api we’ve done all the sql mistakes lists: 10 common mistakes java developers make when writing sql 10 more common mistakes java developers make when writing sql yet another 10 common mistakes java developers make when writing sql (you won’t believe the last one) but we haven’t done a top 10 mistakes list with java 8 yet! for today’s occasion ( it’s friday the 13th ), we’ll catch up with what will go wrong in your application when you’re working with java 8. (it won’t happen to us, as we’re stuck with java 6 for another while) 1. accidentally reusing streams wanna bet, this will happen to everyone at least once. like the existing “streams” (e.g. inputstream ), you can consume streams only once. the following code won’t work: intstream stream = intstream.of(1, 2); stream.foreach(system.out::println); // that was fun! let's do it again! stream.foreach(system.out::println); you’ll get a java.lang.illegalstateexception: stream has already been operated upon or closed so be careful when consuming your stream. it can be done only once 2. accidentally creating “infinite” streams you can create infinite streams quite easily without noticing. take the following example: // will run indefinitely intstream.iterate(0, i -> i + 1) .foreach(system.out::println); the whole point of streams is the fact that they can be infinite, if you design them to be. the only problem is, that you might not have wanted that. so, be sure to always put proper limits: // that's better intstream.iterate(0, i -> i + 1) .limit(10) .foreach(system.out::println); 3. accidentally creating “subtle” infinite streams we can’t say this enough. you will eventually create an infinite stream, accidentally. take the following stream, for instance: intstream.iterate(0, i -> ( i + 1) % 2) .distinct() .limit(10) .foreach(system.out::println); so… we generate alternating 0′s and 1′s then we keep only distinct values, i.e. a single 0 and a single 1 then we limit the stream to a size of 10 then we consume it well… the distinct() operation doesn’t know that the function supplied to the iterate() method will produce only two distinct values. it might expect more than that. so it’ll forever consume new values from the stream, and the limit(10) will never be reached. tough luck, your application stalls. 4. accidentally creating “subtle” parallel infinite streams we really need to insist that you might accidentally try to consume an infinite stream. let’s assume you believe that the distinct() operation should be performed in parallel. you might be writing this: intstream.iterate(0, i -> ( i + 1) % 2) .parallel() .distinct() .limit(10) .foreach(system.out::println); now, we’ve already seen that this will turn forever. but previously, at least, you only consumed one cpu on your machine. now, you’ll probably consume four of them, potentially occupying pretty much all of your system with an accidental infinite stream consumption. that’s pretty bad. you can probably hard-reboot your server / development machine after that. have a last look at what my laptop looked like prior to exploding: if i were a laptop, this is how i’d like to go. 5. mixing up the order of operations so, why did we insist on your definitely accidentally creating infinite streams? it’s simple. because you may just accidentally do it. the above stream can be perfectly consumed if you switch the order of limit() and distinct() : intstream.iterate(0, i -> ( i + 1) % 2) .limit(10) .distinct() .foreach(system.out::println); this now yields: 0 1 why? because we first limit the infinite stream to 10 values (0 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 1), before we reduce the limited stream to the distinct values contained in it (0 1). of course, this may no longer be semantically correct, because you really wanted the first 10 distinct values from a set of data (you just happened to have “forgotten” that the data is infinite). no one really wants 10 random values, and only then reduce them to be distinct. if you’re coming from a sql background, you might not expect such differences. take sql server 2012, for instance. the following two sql statements are the same: -- using top selectdistincttop10 * fromi orderby.. -- using fetch select* fromi orderby.. offset 0 rows fetchnext10 rowsonly so, as a sql person, you might not be as aware of the importance of the order of streams operations. 6. mixing up the order of operations (again) speaking of sql, if you’re a mysql or postgresql person, you might be used to the limit .. offset clause. sql is full of subtle quirks, and this is one of them. the offset clause is applied first , as suggested in sql server 2012′s (i.e. the sql:2008 standard’s) syntax. if you translate mysql / postgresql’s dialect directly to streams, you’ll probably get it wrong: intstream.iterate(0, i -> i + 1) .limit(10) // limit .skip(5) // offset .foreach(system.out::println); the above yields 5 6 7 8 9 yes. it doesn’t continue after 9 , because the limit() is now applied first , producing (0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9). skip() is applied after, reducing the stream to (5 6 7 8 9). not what you may have intended. beware of the limit .. offset vs. "offset .. limit" trap! 7. walking the file system with filters we’ve blogged about this before . what appears to be a good idea is to walk the file system using filters: files.walk(paths.get(".")) .filter(p -> !p.tofile().getname().startswith(".")) .foreach(system.out::println); the above stream appears to be walking only through non-hidden directories, i.e. directories that do not start with a dot. unfortunately, you’ve again made mistake #5 and #6. walk() has already produced the whole stream of subdirectories of the current directory. lazily, though, but logically containing all sub-paths. now, the filter will correctly filter out paths whose names start with a dot “.”. e.g. .git or .idea will not be part of the resulting stream. but these paths will be: .\.git\refs , or .\.idea\libraries . not what you intended. now, don’t fix this by writing the following: files.walk(paths.get(".")) .filter(p -> !p.tostring().contains(file.separator + ".")) .foreach(system.out::println); while that will produce the correct output, it will still do so by traversing the complete directory subtree, recursing into all subdirectories of “hidden” directories. i guess you’ll have to resort to good old jdk 1.0 file.list() again. the good news is, filenamefilter and filefilter are both functional interfaces. 8. modifying the backing collection of a stream while you’re iterating a list , you must not modify that same list in the iteration body. that was true before java 8, but it might become more tricky with java 8 streams. consider the following list from 0..9: // of course, we create this list using streams: list list = intstream.range(0, 10) .boxed() .collect(tocollection(arraylist::new)); now, let’s assume that we want to remove each element while consuming it: list.stream() // remove(object), not remove(int)! .peek(list::remove) .foreach(system.out::println); interestingly enough, this will work for some of the elements! the output you might get is this one: 0 2 4 6 8 null null null null null java.util.concurrentmodificationexception if we introspect the list after catching that exception, there’s a funny finding. we’ll get: [1, 3, 5, 7, 9] heh, it “worked” for all the odd numbers. is this a bug? no, it looks like a feature. if you’re delving into the jdk code, you’ll find this comment in arraylist.arralistspliterator : /* * if arraylists were immutable, or structurally immutable (no * adds, removes, etc), we could implement their spliterators * with arrays.spliterator. instead we detect as much * interference during traversal as practical without * sacrificing much performance. we rely primarily on * modcounts. these are not guaranteed to detect concurrency * violations, and are sometimes overly conservative about * within-thread interference, but detect enough problems to * be worthwhile in practice. to carry this out, we (1) lazily * initialize fence and expectedmodcount until the latest * point that we need to commit to the state we are checking * against; thus improving precision. (this doesn't apply to * sublists, that create spliterators with current non-lazy * values). (2) we perform only a single * concurrentmodificationexception check at the end of foreach * (the most performance-sensitive method). when using foreach * (as opposed to iterators), we can normally only detect * interference after actions, not before. further * cme-triggering checks apply to all other possible * violations of assumptions for example null or too-small * elementdata array given its size(), that could only have * occurred due to interference. this allows the inner loop * of foreach to run without any further checks, and * simplifies lambda-resolution. while this does entail a * number of checks, note that in the common case of * list.stream().foreach(a), no checks or other computation * occur anywhere other than inside foreach itself. the other * less-often-used methods cannot take advantage of most of * these streamlinings. */ now, check out what happens when we tell the stream to produce sorted() results: list.stream() .sorted() .peek(list::remove) .foreach(system.out::println); this will now produce the following, “expected” output 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 and the list after stream consumption? it is empty: [] so, all elements are consumed, and removed correctly. the sorted() operation is a “stateful intermediate operation” , which means that subsequent operations no longer operate on the backing collection, but on an internal state. it is now “safe” to remove elements from the list! well… can we really? let’s proceed with parallel() , sorted() removal: list.stream() .sorted() .parallel() .peek(list::remove) .foreach(system.out::println); this now yields: 7 6 2 5 8 4 1 0 9 3 and the list contains [8] eek. we didn’t remove all elements!? free beers ( and jooq stickers ) go to anyone who solves this streams puzzler! this all appears quite random and subtle, we can only suggest that you never actually do modify a backing collection while consuming a stream. it just doesn’t work. 9. forgetting to actually consume the stream what do you think the following stream does? intstream.range(1, 5) .peek(system.out::println) .peek(i -> { if(i == 5) thrownewruntimeexception("bang"); }); when you read this, you might think that it will print (1 2 3 4 5) and then throw an exception. but that’s not correct. it won’t do anything. the stream just sits there, never having been consumed. as with any fluent api or dsl, you might actually forget to call the “terminal” operation. this might be particularly true when you use peek() , as peek() is an aweful lot similar to foreach() . this can happen with jooq just the same, when you forget to call execute() or fetch() : dsl.using(configuration) .update(table) .set(table.col1, 1) .set(table.col2, "abc") .where(table.id.eq(3)); oops. no execute() yes, the “best” way – with 1-2 caveats ;-) 10. parallel stream deadlock this is now a real goodie for the end! all concurrent systems can run into deadlocks, if you don’t properly synchronise things. while finding a real-world example isn’t obvious, finding a forced example is. the following parallel() stream is guaranteed to run into a deadlock: object[] locks = { newobject(), newobject() }; intstream .range(1, 5) .parallel() .peek(unchecked.intconsumer(i -> { synchronized(locks[i % locks.length]) { thread.sleep(100); synchronized(locks[(i + 1) % locks.length]) { thread.sleep(50); } } })) .foreach(system.out::println); note the use of unchecked.intconsumer() , which transforms the functional intconsumer interface into a org.jooq.lambda.fi.util.function.checkedintconsumer , which is allowed to throw checked exceptions. well. tough luck for your machine. those threads will be blocked forever :-) the good news is, it has never been easier to produce a schoolbook example of a deadlock in java! for more details, see also brian goetz’s answer to this question on stack overflow . conclusion with streams and functional thinking, we’ll run into a massive amount of new, subtle bugs. few of these bugs can be prevented, except through practice and staying focused. you have to think about how to order your operations. you have to think about whether your streams may be infinite. streams (and lambdas) are a very powerful tool. but a tool which we need to get a hang of, first.
June 16, 2014
by Lukas Eder
· 10,347 Views · 2 Likes
article thumbnail
Anomaly Detection : A Survey
this post is summary of the “anomaly detection : a survey”. anomaly detection refers to the problem of finding patterns in data that do not conform to expected behavior. these non-conforming patterns are often referred to as anomalies, outliers, discordant observations, exceptions, aberrations, surprises, peculiarities or contaminants in different application domains. anomalies are patterns in data that do not conform to a well defined notion of normal behavior. interesting to analyze unwanted noise in the data also can be found in there. novelty detection which aims at detecting previously unobserved (emergent, novel) patterns in the data challenges for anomaly detection drawing the boundary between normal and anomalous behavior availability of labeled data noisy data type of anomaly anomalies can be classified into following three categories point anomalies - an individual data instance can be considered as anomalous with respect to the rest of data contextual anomalies - a data instance is anomalous in a specific context (but not otherwise), then it is termed as a contextual anomaly (also referred as conditional anomaly). each data instance is defined using following two sets of attributes contextual attributes. the contextual attributes are used to determine the context (or neighborhood) for that instance eg: in time- series data, time is a contextual attribute which determines the position of an instance on the entire sequence behavioral attributes. the behavioral attributes define the non-contextual characteristics of an instance eg: in a spatial data set describing the average rainfall of the entire world, the amount of rainfall at any location is a behavioral attribute to explain this we will look into "exchange rate history for converting united states dollar (usd) to sri lankan rupee (lkr)"[1] contextual anomaly t2 in a exchange rate time series. note that the exchange rate at time t1 is same as that at time t2 but occurs in a different context and hence is not considered as an anomaly 3. collective anomalies - a collection of related data instances is anomalous with respect to the entire data set data labels the labels associated with a data instance denote if that instance is normal or anomalous. depending labels availability, anomaly detection techniques can be operated in one of the following three modes supervised anomaly detection - techniques trained in supervised mode assume the availability of a training data set which has labeled instances for normal as well as anomaly class semi-supervised anomaly detection - techniques that operate in a semi-supervised mode, assume that the training data has labeled instances for only the normal class. since they do not require labels for the anomaly class unsupervised anomaly detection - techniques that operate in unsupervised mode do not require training data, and thus are most widely applicable. the techniques implicit assume that normal instances are far more frequent than anomalies in the test data. if this assumption is not true then such techniques suffer from high false alarm rate output of anomaly detection anomaly detection have two types of output techniques scores. scoring techniques assign an anomaly score to each instance in the test data depending on the degree to which that instance is considered an anomaly labels. techniques in this category assign a label (normal or anomalous) to each test instance applications of anomaly detection intrusion detection intrusion detection refers to detection of malicious activity. the key challenge for anomaly detection in this domain is the huge volume of data. thus, semi-supervised and unsupervised anomaly detection techniques are preferred in this domain.denning[3] classifies intrusion detection systems into host based and net- work based intrusion detection systems. host based intrusion detection systems - this deals with operating system call traces network intrusion detection systems - these systems deal with detecting intrusions in network data. the intrusions typically occur as anomalous patterns (point anomalies) though certain techniques model[4] the data in a sequential fashion and detect anomalous subsequences (collective anomalies). a challenge faced by anomaly detection techniques in this domain is that the nature of anomalies keeps changing over time as the intruders adapt their network attacks to evade the existing intrusion detection solutions. fraud detection fraud detection refers to detection of criminal activities occurring in commercial organizations such as banks, credit card companies, insurance agencies, cell phone companies, stock market, etc. the organizations are interested in immediate detection of such frauds to prevent economic losses. detection techniques used for credit card fraud and network intrusion detection as below. statistical profiling using histograms parametric statisti- cal modeling non-parametric sta- tistical modeling bayesian networks neural networks support vector ma- chines rule-based clustering based nearest neighbor based spectral information theoretic here are some domain in fraud detections credit card fraud detection mobile phone fraud detection insurance claim fraud detection insider trading detection medical and public health anomaly detection anomaly detection in the medical and public health domains typically work with pa- tient records. the data can have anomalies due to several reasons such as abnormal patient condition or instrumentation errors or recording errors. thus the anomaly detection is a very critical problem in this domain and requires high degree of accuracy. industrial damage detection such damages need to be detected early to prevent further escalation and losses. fault detection in mechanical units structural defect detection image processing anomaly detection techniques dealing with images are either interested in any changes in an image over time (motion detection) or in regions which appear ab- normal on the static image. this domain includes satellite imagery. anomaly detection in text data anomaly detection techniques in this domain primarily detect novel topics or events or news stories in a collection of documents or news articles. the anomalies are caused due to a new interesting event or an anomalous topic. sensor networks since the sensor data collected from various wireless sensors has several unique characteristics. references [1] http://themoneyconverter.com/usd/lkr.aspx [2] varun chandola, arindam banerjee, and vipin kumar. 2009. anomaly detection: a survey. acm comput. surv. 41, 3, article 15 (july 2009), 58 pages. doi=10.1145/1541880.1541882 http://doi.acm.org/10.1145/1541880.1541882 [3] denning, d. e. 1987. an intrusion detection model. ieee transactions of software engineer-ing 13, 2, 222–232. [4]gwadera, r., atallah, m. j., and szpankowski, w. 2004. detection of significant sets of episodes in event sequences. in proceedings of the fourth ieee international conference on data mining. ieee computer society, washington, dc, usa, 3–10.
June 16, 2014
by Madhuka Udantha
· 12,958 Views
article thumbnail
Conversion from AXIS2 to CXF
We were developing SOAP web services using AXIS2, now want to move to CXF as now we will be developing REST webservices. Does anyone have steps of changing the AXIS 2 with CXF, tasks to be done to accomplish this. Thanks in advance We were developing SOAP web services using AXIS2, now want to move to CXF as now we will be developing REST webservices. Does anyone have steps of changing the AXIS 2 with CXF, tasks to be done to accomplish this. Thanks in advance
June 12, 2014
by Nishant Raka
· 2,800 Views
article thumbnail
The Mobile Landscape: Cross-Platform Problems and Solutions
This article was originally published in DZone's 2014 Guide to Mobile Development Mobile development has become a ubiquitous part of the software industry, and most developers understand the central dilemma organizations face when building a mobile app: cross-platform development. What options exist for deploying an app to multiple platforms simultaneously? What are the strengths and weaknesses of each platform? The backbone of mobile development is the native application, but there are a growing number of alternatives: web apps provide a browser-based solution, hybrid apps leverage web development skills in a native package, and code translators apply one platform’s native development skillset to the codebase of another. However, the differences can be subtle, and every option carries its own set of drawbacks. NATIVE DEVELOPMENT Native applications are built from the ground up for a specific platform and tailored to fit it. The precise, platform-centered nature of native development means that these apps have no limits in terms of access to APIs and device features, performance optimization, and platform-specific best practices for user interface design. Ideally, every mobile app would be built this way: to suit its exact purpose while utilizing all of the available resources. One of the major benefits of native mobile development is the availability of resources. For example, developers targeting Android have the Android Software Development Kit (SDK) at their disposal, which includes a suite of tools to streamline the development process: the SDK Manager condenses updates and tool installations into a single menu, the AVD Manager provides access to the Android Emulator and other virtual devices, and the Dalvik Debug Monitor Server (DDMS) is a powerful debugging tool, just to name a few. iOS and Windows Phone developers have similar toolsets available in their SDKs, covering everything from the UI and device feature tools of Cocoa Touch in the iOS SDK to the real world testing conditions of the Simulation Dashboard for Windows Phone 8. These toolsets make native SDKs invaluable and thorough resources. Unfortunately, the native SDKs are all robust toolsets that a native developer has to learn for each platform. To develop native apps from scratch (rather than through an intermediate tool), developers must be skilled with the required language, IDE, and development tools for each targeted platform, and if developers with diverse skillsets are not available, additional developers must be hired. This can be a serious problem, given the increasing push to develop on multiple platforms. For example, according to DZone’s 2014 Mobile Developer Survey, 62% of respondents targeted both Android and iOS. The economic constraints of native development are a major factor in the growing popularity of web apps, hybrid apps, code translators, and Mobile Application Development Platforms (MADPs), which allow developers to reach multiple platforms with just one tooling ecosystem. WEB APPS The skillset for building a basic mobile web app is more common than that of native development. Essentially, mobile web apps are just regular websites optimized to look good and function well on mobile devices, and they can provide a quality app-like experience if the developer is very skilled in web technologies. Widely understood front-end web development languages such as HTML, CSS, and JavaScript provide the logic behind a web app, and there are plenty of tools and libraries out there to help web developers direct their skills toward mobile devices. jQuery Mobile and Sencha Touch are two examples of mobile web frameworks that provide UI components and logic for sliders, swipes, and other touch-activated controls that are common to native mobile applications. The community around open source web technologies is another key difference between native and web development. Web technologies like Node.js and AngularJS are some of the most popular projects in the open source community according to GitHub statistics. This suggests that the community support and knowledge base around web technologies is broader than native technologies. In addition to being a more common skill set, mobile web development can also solve a fundamental issue with native application development. Aside from possible browser compatibility issues, web apps present a near-universal cross-platform option. Most APIs and hardware features will not be accessible by web apps, and because they are not discrete applications in the same way that native apps are, web apps cannot be distributed through common means, such as Apple’s App Store and Google’s Android Marketplace. Web apps may be a particularly flexible option, but they lack a presence on fundamental mobile distribution. HYBRID APPS Many of the drawbacks for web apps are alleviated by another cross-platform option built on the same core web development skillset: the hybrid app. Like web apps, hybrid apps require web development skills, but unlike web apps, they include some native features to allow greater flexibility. It gets the name hybrid because it is built with web languages and technologies at its core. With the help of a native packaging tool, it can be deployed just like a native app and access more native device capabilities (device APIs) than a pure web application. A hybrid app is created by first coding the application to run in the device’s native webview, which is basically a stripped-down version of the browser. For iOS this view is called UIWebView, while on Android it’s called WebView. This view can present the HTML and JavaScript files in a full-screen format, and pure web apps can achieve this full-screen view as well. WebKit is the most commonly targeted browser rendering engine because it is used on iOS, Android, and Blackberry. Where a web app really starts to become a hybrid app is when the app is placed inside of a native wrapper, which packages the hybrid app as a discrete application and makes it viable for app store distribution. In addition to the native wrapper, a native bridge allows the app to communicate with device APIs, such as alarm settings, accelerometers, and cameras. The native bridge is an abstraction layer that exposes the device APIs to the hybrid app as a JavaScript API. This is one feature that clearly separates hybrid and pure web apps, because web apps are unable to pass through the security structures between the browser and native device APIs. Access to many of the hardware features on mobile devices makes hybrid apps feel more like native apps than web apps from the user perspective. MADPS AND CODE TRANSLATORS Some tools can go even further in terms of taking a single codebase and deploying it on multiple mobile platforms. MADPs are development tools, sometimes including a mobile middleware server, that build hybrid or native apps for each platform using one codebase. Some MADPs, such as Appcelerator’s Titanium and Trigger.io, can take advantage of native elements where native is necessary or higher performing. UI widgets may be native, for instance, while a more flexible JavaScript API condenses the universal parts of mobile development and maximizes code reuse. As more native elements are introduced, some of the drawbacks of native development reappear, such as the costly need for multiple skillsets. MADPs are most useful in scenarios where an application needs to work with many back-end data sources, many other mobile apps, or many operating systems. (Inspired by Trigger.io) A less comprehensive but more straightforward solution is to use code translators when building native apps for multiple operating systems. These tools take native code and translate it into another platform’s native code, or translate native code into a neutral low-level alternative, such as bytecode. One example is Google’s J2ObjC, which translates Java classes into their Objective-C equivalents, alleviating a lot the initial development of an iOS version of the app. Although it’s much more than a code translator, a product called Xamarin does something similar by allowing developers working with C# and .NET in Visual Studio to produce a native ARM executable. They can then take advantage of ahead-of-time (AOT) or just-in-time (JIT) compilation to run their apps on iOS and Android in addition to Windows Phone. As is the case with hybrid apps, the UI presents a problem. Because UI development cannot be translated between platforms, code translators still require a significant knowledge of the native platform to write the UI. In other words, code translators can provide substantial benefits in terms of cutting down development time, but they’re not necessarily a “write once, run anywhere” solution. NO SILVER BULLETS Between native apps, web apps, hybrid apps, and the growing number of MADPs, there are a lot of options for mobile development. It’s important to note that there is no one solution that does everything. Some sacrifice affordability and accessibility for pure native performance, UI for easy cross-platform deployment, or ease of development for native authenticity. Even the simplest tools come with some degree of a learning curve. If a method with no trade-offs existed, the industry would adopt it en masse, and you would know about it. Because there are trade-offs, developers and decision-makers will have to recognize their needs, and the needs of their users, in order to determine the best way to approach mobile development. Want to read more articles like this? Download the free guide today! 2014 Guide to Mobile Development DZone's 2014 Guide to Mobile Development provides an analysis of the current state of mobile development and important strategies, tools, and insights for accelerating mobile development and includes: In-depth articles written by industry experts Survey results from over 1000 mobile developers Profiles on 39 mobile developement tools and frameworks And much more! DOWNLOAD NOW
June 11, 2014
by Alec Noller
· 11,908 Views
article thumbnail
Automating the Continuous Integration of Android Projects With Gradle Using Jenkins on Windows
this post will show how to automate the deployment process of a android application using jenkins continuous integration – to build the project, run the unit tests (if any), archive the built artifacts and run the android lint reports. 1. install jenkins as a windows service navigate to jenkins-ci.org website using an internet browser and download the windows native package (the link is underlined for easy identification) as shown from the right side pane of the download jenkins tab. once the download is complete, uncompress the zip file and click on the jenkins-1.xxx.msi file. proceed through the configuration steps to install the jenkins as a windows service. 2. modify default jenkins port by default jenkins runs on the port 8080. in order to avoid conflict with other applications, the default port can be modified by editing the jenkins.xml found under c:\program files (x86)\jenkins location. as shown below, modify the httpport to 8082. jenkins jenkins this service runs jenkins continuous integration system. %base%\jre\bin\java -xrs -xmx256m -dhudson.lifecycle=hudson.lifecycle.windowsservicelifecycle -jar "%base%\jenkins.war" --httpport=8082 rotate once the modification is saved in jenkins.xml file, restart the jenkins service from the windows task manager->services and right clicking on the jenkins service and choose stop service to stop the service as shown below. once the status of the service changes to stopped, restart the service by right clicking on the jenkins service and choose start service to start the service again. navigate to localhost:8082 to verify if the jenkins restart was successful as shown below – jenkins dashboard will be displayed. note that it takes a while before the jenkins service becomes available. 3. install plugins on the jenkins dashboard, navigate to manage jenkins –> manage plugins as shown in the snapshot below. install the following plugins and restart jenkins for the changes to take effect. git plugin (for integrating git with jenkins) gradle plugin (for integrating gradle with jenkins) android lint plugin (for integration lint with jenkins) 4. configure system on the jenkins dashboard, navigate to manage jenkins –> configure system as shown in the snapshot below. navigate to the global properties section and click on add to add an environment variable android_home as shown in the snapshot below. enter the name as android_home and enter the path of the location where the android sdk is stored on windows. navigate to the jdk section and click on “add jdk” to add the jdk installation as shown in the snapshot below. specify a jdk name, choose the jdk version to install and follow the on-screen instructions to save the oracle login credentials. save the changes. next, proceed to the git section and click on “add git” to add the git installation as shown in the snapshot below. specify git name, specify the path to git executable and save the changes. next, proceed to the gradle section and click on “add gradle” to add the gradle installation as shown in the snapshot below. specify gradle name, choose the appropriate version (at the time of writing, i used gradle 1.10) and save the changes. next, proceed to the email notification section and enter the smtp server details as shown below. click on the advanced button to add the further details required and save the changes. click on “test configuration by sending test e-mail”, enter the test e-mail recipient and click on “test configuration” to see if the email is successfully sent. 5. create a new jenkins job from the jenkins dashboard, click on “new job” to create a new job. enter a name for the job and choose “build a free-style software project” as option and click on ok as shown below. from the new job configuration screen, proceed to the source code management section. save the git credentials by clicking on “add” as shown below and entering the details in the following dialog. save the changes by clicking on “add” as shown below. specify the git repository url for the project, choose the saved credentials from the drop-down list as shown in the snapshot below. save the changes. next, from the build triggers section, select the options desired as shown below and save the changes. proceed to the build section, choose “invoke gradle script” from the drop-down list of choices for “add build step”. choose the appropriate gradle version which is configured, enter the tasks to be built and select the options as desired. save the changes. proceed to the post-build actions section, click on “publish android lint results” from the drop-down list of choices for “add post-build action” and specify the location where the lint results should be stored in the jenkins workspace for the job. similarly, click on “archive the artifacts” from the drop-down list of choices for “add post-build action” and the specify the format of apk files to be archived after every build. additionally, options from advanced section such as “discard all but the last successful/stable artifact to save disk space” could be enabled for saving disk space. click on “e-mail notification” from the drop-down list of choices for “add post-build action” and enter the values for the email recipients as shown below. save the changes. 6. build now once the above configuration steps are complete, click on “build now” under the jenkins –> build android application (or the respective job name) to build the project based on the configuration. the console output has the detailed logs of what steps were initiated by the configuration and the outcome of the entire build. clicking on any successful build outcome shows the artifacts that were archived as part of the build, the change that started the build and the lint results as shown below. thus the entire process of building the project an android application project whenever a scm change is triggered or under another condition, running lint reports, archiving the artifacts built, publishing lint reports and triggering emails to the recipients can be automated with a click of a button through jenkins.
June 11, 2014
by Elizabeth Thomas
· 53,822 Views · 8 Likes
article thumbnail
Building a Simple RESTful API with Java Spark
Disclaimer: This post is about the Java micro web framework named Spark and not about the data processing engine Apache Spark. In this blog post we will see how Spark can be used to build a simple web service. As mentioned in the disclaimer, Spark is a micro web framework for Java inspired by the Ruby framework Sinatra. Spark aims for simplicity and provides only a minimal set of features. However, it provides everything needed to build a web application in a few lines of Java code. Getting Started Let's assume we have a simple domain class with a few properties and a service that provides some basic CRUDfunctionality: public class User { private String id; private String name; private String email; // getter/setter } public class UserService { // returns a list of all users public List getAllUsers() { .. } // returns a single user by id public User getUser(String id) { .. } // creates a new user public User createUser(String name, String email) { .. } // updates an existing user public User updateUser(String id, String name, String email) { .. } } We now want to expose the functionality of UserService as a RESTful API (For simplicity we will skip the hypermedia part of REST ;-)). For accessing, creating and updating user objects we want to use following URL patterns: GET /users Get a list of all users GET /users/ Get a specific user POST /users Create a new user PUT /users/ Update a user The returned data should be in JSON format. To get started with Spark we need the following Maven dependencies: com.sparkjava spark-core 2.0.0 org.slf4j slf4j-simple 1.7.7 Spark uses SLF4J for logging, so we need to a SLF4J binder to see log and error messages. In this example we use the slf4j-simple dependency for this purpose. However, you can also use Log4j or any other binder you like. Having slf4j-simple in the classpath is enough to see log output in the console. We will also use GSON for generating JSON output and JUnit to write a simple integration tests. You can find these dependencies in the complete pom.xml. Returning All Users Now it is time to create a class that is responsible for handling incoming requests. We start by implementing the GET /users request that should return a list of all users. import static spark.Spark.*; public class UserController { public UserController(final UserService userService) { get("/users", new Route() { @Override public Object handle(Request request, Response response) { // process request return userService.getAllUsers(); } }); // more routes } } Note the static import of spark.Spark.* in the first line. This gives us access to various static methods including get(), post(), put() and more. Within the constructor the get() method is used to register aRoute that listens for GET requests on /users. A Route is responsible for processing requests. Whenever aGET /users request is made, the handle() method will be called. Inside handle() we return an object that should be sent to the client (in this case a list of all users). Spark highly benefits from Java 8 Lambda expressions. Route is a functional interface (it contains only one method), so we can implement it using a Java 8 Lambda expression. Using a Lambda expression the Routedefinition from above looks like this: get("/users", (req, res) -> userService.getAllUsers()); To start the application we have to create a simple main() method. Inside main() we create an instance of our service and pass it to our newly created UserController: public class Main { public static void main(String[] args) { new UserController(new UserService()); } } If we now run main(), Spark will start an embedded Jetty server that listens on Port 4567. We can test our first route by initiating a GET http://localhost:4567/users request. In case the service returns a list with two user objects the response body might look like this: [com.mscharhag.sparkdemo.User@449c23fd, com.mscharhag.sparkdemo.User@437b26fe] Obviously this is not the response we want. Spark uses an interface called ResponseTransformer to convert objects returned by routes to an actual HTTP response. ReponseTransformer looks like this: public interface ResponseTransformer { String render(Object model) throws Exception; } ResponseTransformer has a single method that takes an object and returns a String representation of this object. The default implementation of ResponseTransformer simply calls toString() on the passed object (which creates output like shown above). Since we want to return JSON we have to create a ResponseTransformer that converts the passed objects to JSON. We use a small JsonUtil class with two static methods for this: public class JsonUtil { public static String toJson(Object object) { return new Gson().toJson(object); } public static ResponseTransformer json() { return JsonUtil::toJson; } } toJson() is an universal method that converts an object to JSON using GSON. The second method makes use of Java 8 method references to return a ResponseTransformer instance. ResponseTransformer is again a functional interface, so it can be satisfied by providing an appropriate method implementation (toJson()). So whenever we call json() we get a new ResponseTransformer that makes use of our toJson()method. In our UserController we can pass a ResponseTransformer as a third argument to Spark's get()method: import static com.mscharhag.sparkdemo.JsonUtil.*; public class UserController { public UserController(final UserService userService) { get("/users", (req, res) -> userService.getAllUsers(), json()); ... } } Note again the static import of JsonUtil.* in the first line. This gives us the option to create a newResponseTransformer by simply calling json(). Our response looks now like this: [{ "id": "1866d959-4a52-4409-afc8-4f09896f38b2", "name": "john", "email": "[email protected]" },{ "id": "90d965ad-5bdf-455d-9808-c38b72a5181a", "name": "anna", "email": "[email protected]" }] We still have a small problem. The response is returned with the wrong Content-Type. To fix this, we can register a Filter that sets the JSON Content-Type: after((req, res) -> { res.type("application/json"); }); Filter is again a functional interface and can therefore be implemented by a short Lambda expression. After a request is handled by our Route, the filter changes the Content-Type of every response toapplication/json. We can also use before() instead of after() to register a filter. Then, the Filterwould be called before the request is processed by the Route. The GET /users request should be working now :-) Returning a Specific User To return a specific user we simply create a new route in our UserController: get("/users/:id", (req, res) -> { String id = req.params(":id"); User user = userService.getUser(id); if (user != null) { return user; } res.status(400); return new ResponseError("No user with id '%s' found", id); }, json()); With req.params(":id") we can obtain the :id path parameter from the URL. We pass this parameter to our service to get the corresponding user object. We assume the service returns null if no user with the passed id is found. In this case, we change the HTTP status code to 400 (Bad Request) and return an error object. ResponseError is a small helper class we use to convert error messages and exceptions to JSON. It looks like this: public class ResponseError { private String message; public ResponseError(String message, String... args) { this.message = String.format(message, args); } public ResponseError(Exception e) { this.message = e.getMessage(); } public String getMessage() { return this.message; } } We are now able to query for a single user with a request like this: GET /users/5f45a4ff-35a7-47e8-b731-4339c84962be If an user with this id exists we will get a response that looks somehow like this: { "id": "5f45a4ff-35a7-47e8-b731-4339c84962be", "name": "john", "email": "[email protected]" } If we use an invalid user id, a ResponseError object will be created and converted to JSON. In this case the response looks like this: { "message": "No user with id 'foo' found" } Creating and Updating Users Creating and updating users is again very easy. Like returning the list of all users it is done using a single service call: post("/users", (req, res) -> userService.createUser( req.queryParams("name"), req.queryParams("email") ), json()); put("/users/:id", (req, res) -> userService.updateUser( req.params(":id"), req.queryParams("name"), req.queryParams("email") ), json()); To register a route for HTTP POST or PUT requests we simply use the static post() and put() methods of Spark. Inside a Route we can access HTTP POST parameters using req.queryParams(). For simplicity reasons (and to show another Spark feature) we do not do any validation inside the routes. Instead we assume that the service will throw an IllegalArgumentException if we pass in invalid values. Spark gives us the option to register ExceptionHandlers. An ExceptionHandler will be called if anException is thrown while processing a route. ExceptionHandler is another single method interface we can implement using a Java 8 Lambda expression: exception(IllegalArgumentException.class, (e, req, res) -> { res.status(400); res.body(toJson(new ResponseError(e))); }); Here we create an ExceptionHandler that is called if an IllegalArgumentException is thrown. The caught Exception object is passed as the first parameter. We set the response code to 400 and add an error message to the response body. If the service throws an IllegalArgumentException when the email parameter is empty, we might get a response like this: { "message": "Parameter 'email' cannot be empty" } The complete source the controller can be found here. Testing Because of Spark's simple nature it is very easy to write integration tests for our sample application. Let's start with this basic JUnit test setup: public class UserControllerIntegrationTest { @BeforeClass public static void beforeClass() { Main.main(null); } @AfterClass public static void afterClass() { Spark.stop(); } ... } In beforeClass() we start our application by simply running the main() method. After all tests finished we call Spark.stop(). This stops the embedded server that runs our application. After that we can send HTTP requests within test methods and validate that our application returns the correct response. A simple test that sends a request to create a new user can look like this: @Test public void aNewUserShouldBeCreated() { TestResponse res = request("POST", "/users?name=john&[email protected]"); Map json = res.json(); assertEquals(200, res.status); assertEquals("john", json.get("name")); assertEquals("[email protected]", json.get("email")); assertNotNull(json.get("id")); } request() and TestResponse are two small self made test utilities. request() sends a HTTP request to the passed URL and returns a TestResponse instance. TestResponse is just a small wrapper around some HTTP response data. The source of request() and TestResponse is included in the complete test classfound on GitHub. Conclusion Compared to other web frameworks Spark provides only a small amount of features. However, it is so simple you can build small web applications within a few minutes (even if you have not used Spark before). If you want to look into Spark you should clearly use Java 8, which reduces the amount of code you have to write a lot. You can find the complete source of the sample project on GitHub.
June 9, 2014
by Michael Scharhag
· 111,697 Views · 3 Likes
article thumbnail
An Architecturally-Evident Coding Style
okay, this is the separate blog post that i referred to in software architecture vs code . what exactly do we mean by an "architecturally-evident coding style"? i built a simple content aggregator for the local tech community here in jersey called techtribes.je , which is basically made up of a web server, a couple of databases and a standalone java application that is responsible for actually aggegrating the content displayed on the website. you can read a little more about the software architecture at techtribes.je - containers . the following diagram is a zoom-in of the standalone content updater application, showing how it's been decomposed. this diagram says that the content updater application is made up of a number of core components (which are shown on a separate diagram for brevity) and an additional four components - a scheduled content updater, a twitter connector, a github connector and a news feed connector. this diagram shows a really nice, simple architecture view of how my standalone content updater application has been decomposed into a small number of components. "component" is a hugely overloaded term in the software development industry, but essentially all i'm referring to is a collection of related behaviour sitting behind a nice clean interface. back to the "architecturally-evident coding style" and the basic premise is that the code should reflect the architecture. in other words, if i look at the code, i should be able to clearly identify each of the components that i've shown on the diagram. since the code for techtribes.je is open source and on github, you can go and take a look for yourself as to whether this is the case. and it is ... there's a je.techtribes.component package that contains sub-packages for each of the components shown on the diagram. from a technical perspective, each of these are simply spring beans with a public interface and a package-protected implementation. that's it; the code reflects the architecture as illustrated on the diagram. so what about those core components then? well, here's a diagram showing those. again, this diagram shows a nice simple decomposition of the core of my techtribes.je system into coarse-grained components. and again, browsing the source code will reveal the same one-to-one mapping between boxes on the diagram and packages in the code. this requires conscious effort to do but i like the simple and explicit nature of the relationship between the architecture and the code. when architecture and code don't match the interesting part of this story is that while i'd always viewed my system as a collection of "components", the code didn't actually look like that. to take an example, there's a tweet component on the core components diagram, which basically provides crud access to tweets in a mongodb database. the diagram suggests that it's a single black box component, but my initial implementation was very different. the following diagram illustrates why. my initial implementation of the tweet component looked like the picture on the left - i'd taken a "package by layer" approach and broken my tweet component down into a separate service and data access object. this is your stereotypical layered architecture that many (most?) books and tutorials present as a way to build (e.g.) web applications. it's also pretty much how i've built most software in the past too and i'm sure you've seen the same, especially in systems that use a dependency injection framework where we create a bunch of things in layers and wire them all together. layered architectures have a number of benefits but they aren't a silver bullet . this is a great example of where the code doesn't quite reflect the architecture - the tweet component is a single box on an architecture diagram but implemented as a collection of classes across a layered architecture when you look at the code. imagine having a large, complex codebase where the architecture diagrams tell a different story from the code. the easy way to fix this is to simply redraw the core components diagram to show that it's really a layered architecture made up of services collaborating with data access objects. the result is a much more complex diagram but it also feels like that diagram is starting to show too much detail. the other option is to change the code to match my architectural vision. and that's what i did. i reorganised the code to be packaged by component rather than packaged by layer. in essence, i merged the services and data access objects together into a single package so that i was left with a public interface and a package protected implementation. here's the tweet component on github . but what about... again, there's a clean simple mapping from the diagram into the code and the code cleanly reflects the architecture. it does raise a number of interesting questions though. why aren't you using a layered architecture? where did the tweetdao interface go? how do you mock out your dao implementation to do unit testing? what happens if i want to call the dao directly? what happens if you want to change the way that you store tweets? layers are now an implementation detail this is still a layered architecture, it's just that the layers are now a component implementation detail rather than being first-class architectural building blocks. and that's nice, because i can think about my components as being my architecturally significant structural elements and it's these building blocks that are defined in my dependency injection framework. something i often see in layered architectures is code bypassing a services layer to directly access a dao or repository. these sort of shortcuts are exactly why layered architectures often become corrupted and turn into big balls of mud. in my codebase, if any consumer wants access to tweets, they are forced to use the tweet component in its entirety because the dao is an internal implementation detail. and because i have layers inside my component, i can still switch out my tweet data storage from mongodb to something else. that change is still isolated. component testing vs unit testing ah, unit testing. bundling up my tweet service and dao into a single component makes the resulting tweet component harder to unit test because everything is package protected. sure, it's not impossible to provide a mock implementation of the mongodbtweetdao but i need to jump through some hoops. the other approach is to simply not do unit testing and instead test my tweet component through its public interface. dhh recently published a blog post called test-induced design damage and i agree with the overall message; perhaps we are breaking up our systems unnecessarily just in order to unit test them. there's very little to be gained from unit testing the various sub-parts of my tweet component in isolation, so in this case i've opted to do automated component testing instead where i test the component as a black-box through its component interface. mongodb is lightweight and fast, with the resulting component tests running acceptably quick for me, even on my ageing macbook air. i'm not saying that you should never unit test code in isolation, and indeed there are some situations where component testing isn't feasible. for example, if you're using asynchronous and/or third party services, you probably do want to ability to provide a mock implementation for unit testing. the point is that we shouldn't blindly create designs where everything can be mocked out and unit tested in isolation. food for thought the purpose of this blog post was to provide some more detail around how to ensure that code reflects architecture and to illustrate an approach to do this. i like the structure imposed by forcing my codebase to reflect the architecture. it requires some discipline and thinking about how to neatly carve-up the responsibilities across the codebase, but i think the effort is rewarded. it's also a nice stepping stone towards micro-services. my techtribes.je system is constructed from a number of in-process components that i treat as my architectural building blocks. the thinking behind creating a micro-services architecture is essentially the same, albeit the components (services) are running out-of-process. this isn't a silver bullet by any means, but i hope it's provided some food for thought around designing software and structuring a codebase with an architecturally-evident coding style.
June 9, 2014
by Simon Brown
· 6,303 Views
article thumbnail
MapDB: The Agile Java Data Engine
MapDB is a pure Java database, specifically designed for the Java developer. The fundamental concept for MapDB is very clever yet natural to use: provide a reliable, full-featured and “tune-able” database engine using the Java Collections API. MapDB 1.0 has just been released, this is the culmination of years of research and development to get the project to this point. Jan Kotek, the primary developer for MapDB, also worked on predecessor projects (JDBM), starting MapDB as an entire from-scratch rewrite. Jan’s expertise and dedication to low-level debugging has yielded excellent results, producting an easy-to-use database for Java with comparable performance to many C-based engines. What sets MapDB apart is the “map” concept. The idea is to leverage the totally natural Java Collections API – so familiar to Java developers that most of them literally use it daily in their work. For most database interactions with a Java application, some sort of translator is required. There are many Object-Relational Mapping (ORM) tools to name just one category of such components. The goal has always been in the direction of making it natural to code in objects in the Java language, and translate them to a specific database syntax (such as SQL). However, such efforts have always come up short, adding complexity for both the application developer and the data architect. When using MapDB there is no object “translation layer” – developers just access data in familiar structures like Maps, Sets, Queues, etc. There is no change in syntax from typical Java coding, other than a brief initialization syntax and transaction management. A developer can literally transform memory-limited maps into a high-speed persistent store in seconds (typically changing just one line of code). A MapDB Example Here is a simple MapDB example, showing how easy and intuitive it is to use in a Java application: // Initialize a MapDB database DB db = DBMaker.newFileDB(new File("testdb")) .closeOnJvmShutdown() .make(); // Create a Map: Map myMap = db.getTreeMap(“testmap”); // Work with the Map using the normal Map API. myMap.put(“key1”, “value1”); myMap.put(“key2”, “value2”); String value = myMap.get(“key1”); ... That’s all you need to do, now you have a file-backed Map of virtually any size. Note the “builder-style” initialization syntax, enabling MapDB as the agile database choice for Java. There are many builder options that let you tune your database for the specific requirements at hand. Just a small subset of options include: In-memory implementation Enable transactions Configurable caching This means that you can configure your database just for what you need, effectively making MapDB serve the job of many other databases. MapDB comes with a set of powerful configuration options, and you can even extend the product to make your own data implementations if necessary. Another very powerful feature is that MapDB utilizes some of the advanced Java Collections variants, such as ConcurrentNavigableMap. With this type of Map you can go beyond simple key-value semantics, as it is also a sorted Map allowing you to access data in order, and find values near a key. Not many people are aware of this extension to the Collections API, but it is extremely powerful and allows you to do a lot with your MapDB database (I will cover more of these capabilities in a future article). The Agile Aspect of MapDB When I first met Jan and started talking with him about MapDB he said something that made a very important impression: If you know what data structure you want, MapDB allows you to tailor the structure and database characteristics to your exact application needs. In other words, the schema and ways you can structure your data is very flexible. The configuration of the physical data store is just as flexible, making a perfect combination for meeting almost any database need. They key to this capability is inherent in MapDB’s architecture, and how it translates to the MapDB API itself. Here is a simple diagram of the MapDB architecture: As you can see from the diagram, there are 3 tiers in MapDB: Collections API: This is the familiar Java Collections API that every Java developer uses for maintaining application state. It has a simple builder-style extension to allow you to control the exact characteristics of a given database (including its internal format or record structure). Engine: The Engine is the real key to MapDB, this is where the records for a database – including their internal structure, concurrency control, transactional semantics – are controlled. MapDB ships with several engines already, and it is straightforward to add your own Engine if needed for specialized data handling. Volume: This is the physical storage layer (e.g., on-disk or in-memory). MapDB has a few standard Volume implementations, and they should suffice for most projects. The main point is that the development API is completely distinct from the Engine implementation (the heart of MapDB), and both are separate from the actual physical storage layer. This offers a very agile approach, allowing developers to exactly control what type of internal structure is needed for a given database, and what the actual data structure looks like from the top-level Collections API. To make things even more extensible and agile, MapDB uses a concept of Engine Wrappers. An Engine Wrapper allows adding additional features and options on top of a specific engine layer. For example, if the standard Map engine is utilized for creating a B-Tree backed Map, it is feasible to enable (or disable) caching support. This caching feature is done through an Engine Wrapper, and that is what shows up in the builder-style API used to configure a given database. While a whole article could be written just about this, the point here is that this adds to MapDB’s inherent agile nature. By way of example, here is how you configure a pure in-memory database, without transactional capabilities: // Initialize an in-memory MapDB database // without transactions DB db = DBMaker.newMemoryDB() .transactionDisable() .closeOnJvmShutdown() .make(); // Create a Map: Map myMap = db.getTreeMap(“testmap”); // Work with the Map using the normal Map API. myMap.put(“key1”, “value1”); myMap.put(“key2”, “value2”); String value = myMap.get(“key1”); ... That’s it! All that was needed was to change the DBMaker call to add the new options, everything else works exactly the same as in the example shown earlier. Agile Data Model In addition to customizing the features and performance characteristics of a given database instance, MapDB allows you to create an agile data model, with a schema exactly matching your application requirements. This is probably similar to how you write your code when creating standard Java in-memory structures. For example, let’s say you need to lookup a Person object by username, or by personID. Simply create a Person object and two Maps to meet your needs: public class Person { private Integer personID; private String username; ... // Setters and getters go here ... } // Create a Map of Person by username. Map personByUsernameMap = ... // Create a Map of Person by personID. Map personByPersonIDMap = ... This is a very trivial example, but now you can easily write to both maps for each new Person instance, and subsequently retrieve a Person by either key. Another interesting concept with MapDB data structures are some key extensions to the normal Java Collections API. A common requirement in applications is to have a Map with a key/value, and in addition to finding the value for a key to be able to perform the inverse: lookup the key for a given value. We can easily do this using the MapDB extension for bi-directional maps: // Create a primary map HTreeMap map = DBMaker.newTempHashMap(); // Create the inverse mapping for primary map NavigableSet> inverseMapping = new TreeSet>(); // Bind the inverse mapping to primary map, so it is auto-updated each time the primary map gets a new key/value Bind.mapInverse(map, inverseMapping); map.put(10L,"value2"); map.put(1111L,"value"); map.put(1112L,"value"); map.put(11L,"val"); // Now find a key by a given value. Long keyValue = Fun.filter(inverseMapping.get(“value2”); MapDB supports many constructs for the interaction of Maps or other collections, allowing you to create a schema of related structures that can automatically be kept in sync. This avoids a lot of scanning of structures, makes coding fast and convenient, and can keep things very fast. Wrapping it up I have shown a very brief introduction on MapDB and how the product works. As you can see its strengths are its use of the natural Java Collections API, the agile nature of the engine itself, and the support for virtually any type of data model or schema that your application needs. MapDB is freely available for any use under the Apache 2.0 license. To learn more, check out: www.mapdb.org.
June 5, 2014
by Cory Isaacson
· 28,692 Views · 3 Likes
article thumbnail
Introducing Partitioned Collections for MongoDB Applications
TokuMX 1.5 is around the corner. The big feature will be something we discussed briefly when talking about replication changes in 1.4: partitioned collections. Before introducing the feature, I wanted to mention the following. Although TokuMX 1.5 is not available as of this writing, we would love to hear feedback on partitioned collections, which we think are wonderful for time-series data, as I describe below. If you are interested in trying out the feature, email [email protected] for a pre-release version of TokuMX 1.5. What is a partitioned collection? A partitioned collection is analogous to a partitioned table in relational databases. Oracle, MySQL, SQL Server, and Postgres all support partitioned tables. We are happy to bring this functionality to TokuMX. So, if the remainder of this blog is unclear, and you have friends in the office who are familiar with relational databases, you may want to ask them for more information :). Nevertheless, a partitioned collection is a collection that underneath the covers is broken into (or partitioned into) several individual collections, based on ranges of a “partition key”. From the application developer’s point of view, the collection is just another collection. Queries, inserts, updates, and deletes just work with no syntactical changes. Secondary indexes and replication work as well. But underneath the covers, the data will be broken into several collections, with each collection responsible for all data for a range of the partition key. If you are running TokuMX 1.4, a simple example is the oplog, which is a partitioned collection. Any normal query works just fine on the oplog. However, if you look in your data directory, you will see several .tokumx files named “local_oplog_rs_p…”. These files are the individual partitions that break up the data. Each partition stores a range of _id fields in the oplog. Why should I bother using a partitioned collection? This will be its own post with longer examples, but here is a summary. Partitioned collections have two big advantages: Large chunks of data can be deleted very efficiently by dropping partitions. The cost is that of performing an “rm” on some files in the filesystem. This is really fast and efficient. Queries that include the partition key may be isolated to individual partitions, and therefore run faster. This is similar to “query isolation” for shard keys. So, one scenario you may want a partitioned collection for is where the oldest data gets dropped periodically, and many queries benefit from a time based key. That will be a good fit. In short: time series data. If you have a time-series application where you want to keep a rolling period of data (e.g. the last 6 months worth), then using a partitioned collection will be great, and is preferable to using a TTL index or a capped collection. In a future blog post, I will expand on this. How do I use a partitioned collection in TokuMX 1.5? Basically, just like a normal collection, except with some commands added to create a partitioned collection, add partitions, and drop partitions. Below, I explain the shell commands added for this functionality. Our documentation contains the full commands so that they may be called by any driver’s runCommand method. Ok, so how do I create a partitioned collection? The first thing to consider is what your partition key should be. That is, what key do you want to use ranges of to partition your data? This key has similarities with a shard key. It should be a key that can be used to isolate partitions, the way a shard key is used to isolate shards (as explained here). Also, it should be a key that contains a range of data you would like to delete all at once. With time series data, that key will likely be a timestamp. In TokuMX, the partition key is always the primary key. To create a partitioned collection, “foo”, with a timestamp field, “ts”, used for the partitioning run the following: > db.createCollection("foo", { partitioned : 1 , primaryKey : { ts : 1 , _id : 1 } }) { "ok" : 1 } Note that in TokuMX, the primary key must have the _id field appended to it to ensure uniqueness. As a side note, we do not support hash based partitioning, only range based partitioning. Adding partitions? In TokuMX, partitions can only be appended to the end. Individual partitions cannot be split. So, say we have a collection that partitions on the _id field, where all _id’s happen to be integers. Suppose we have three partitions with the following ranges: _id <= 0 0 < _id <= 1000 _id > 1000 With this collection we cannot create a partition with the range 500 < _id <= 1000, because that would split the second partition. All we can do is add a new partition to the end, and “cap” the current last partition with a new maximum value. This new maximum value must be greater than or equal to the primary key (or in this case, _id) of the last partition’s last document. So, if the last partition’s last document has an _id of 2500, we can only partitions that create a range whose maximum is at least 2500. There are two ways to add a partition. The first method peeks at the last document in the current last partition, caps the partition with the primary key of that last document, and creates a new partition. To do so, one does: > db.foo.addPartition() { "ok" : 1 } In the above example, the partitioned collection would now have partitions with the following ranges: _id <= 0 0 < _id <= 1000 1000 < _id <= 2500 _id > 2500 Alternatively, we can specify what the new maximum of the existing last partition may be, provided it is greater than the last document in last partition (which in this example is 2500). To do so, we simply pass in the new maximum as a parameter: > db.foo.addPartition({ _id : 3000 }); { "ok" : 1 } This would make the collection have partitions with the following ranges: _id <= 0 0 < _id <= 1000 1000 < _id <= 3000 _id > 3000 Dropping partitions? Dropping partitions is simple. First, see what the partitions are with the following shell command: > db.foo.getPartitionInfo() { "numPartitions" : NumberLong(4), "partitions" : [ { "_id" : NumberLong(0), "max" : { "_id" : 0 }, "createTime" : ISODate("2014-05-29T01:50:15.839Z") }, { "_id" : NumberLong(1), "max" : { "_id" : 1000 }, "createTime" : ISODate("2014-05-29T01:50:27.049Z") }, { "_id" : NumberLong(2), "max" : { "_id" : 2500 }, "createTime" : ISODate("2014-05-29T01:50:30.549Z") }, { "_id" : NumberLong(3), "max" : { "_id" : { "$maxKey" : 1 } }, "createTime" : ISODate("2014-05-29T01:50:35.903Z") } ], "ok" : 1 } This lists each partition, what the maximum value that each partition may hold (thus defining the range of the partition), and the id of the partition (in the _id field). So, in the example we used for adding partitions, we have four partitions with _ids 0 through 3. To drop a partition, we run the following command and pass the _id of the partition we want to drop. To drop partition 0, we run: > db.foo.dropPartition(0) { "ok" : 1 } Looking at the list of partitions after this operation, we see the partition is dropped: > db.foo.getPartitionInfo() { "numPartitions" : NumberLong(3), "partitions" : [ { "_id" : NumberLong(1), "max" : { "_id" : 1000 }, "createTime" : ISODate("2014-05-29T01:50:27.049Z") }, { "_id" : NumberLong(2), "max" : { "_id" : 2500 }, "createTime" : ISODate("2014-05-29T01:50:30.549Z") }, { "_id" : NumberLong(3), "max" : { "_id" : { "$maxKey" : 1 } }, "createTime" : ISODate("2014-05-29T01:50:35.903Z") } ], "ok" : 1 } This covers how to use partitioned collections. We hope users in the MongoDB ecosystem find this feature as useful as relational database users do. In the comments section below, feel free to leave questions and/or feedback.
June 4, 2014
by Zardosht Kasheff
· 12,511 Views
article thumbnail
Exploring Message Brokers: RabbitMQ, Kafka, ActiveMQ, and Kestrel
Explore different message brokers, and discover how these important web technologies impact a customer's backlog of messages, and cluster/data performance.
June 3, 2014
by Yves Trudeau
· 460,814 Views · 86 Likes
article thumbnail
Spring Integration Java DSL sample
A new Java based DSL has now been introduced for Spring Integration which makes it possible to define the Spring Integration message flows using pure java based configuration instead of using the Spring XML based configuration. I tried the DSL for a sample Integration flow that I have - I call it the Rube Goldberg flow, for it follows a convoluted path in trying to capitalize a string passed in as input. The flow looks like this and does some crazy things to perform a simple task: It takes in a message of this type - "hello from spring integ" splits it up into individual words(hello, from, spring, integ) sends each word to a ActiveMQ queue from the queue the word fragments are picked up by a enricher to capitalize each word placing the response back into a response queue It is picked up, resequenced based on the original sequence of the words aggregated back into a sentence("HELLO FROM SPRING INTEG") and returned back to the application. To start with Spring Integration Java DSL, a simple Xml based configuration to capitalize a String would look like this: There is nothing much going on here, a messaging gateway takes in the message passed in from the application, capitalizes it in a transformer and this is returned back to the application. Expressing this in Spring Integration Java DSL: @Configuration @EnableIntegration @IntegrationComponentScan @ComponentScan public class EchoFlow { @Bean public DirectChannel requestChannel() { return new DirectChannel(); } @Bean public IntegrationFlow simpleEchoFlow() { return IntegrationFlows.from(requestChannel()) .transform((String s) -> s.toUpperCase()) .get(); } } @MessagingGateway public interface EchoGateway { @Gateway(requestChannel = "requestChannel") String echo(String message); } Do note that @MessagingGateway annotation is not a part of Spring Integration Java DSL, it is an existing component in Spring Integration and serves the same purpose as the gateway component in XML based configuration. I like the fact that the transformation can be expressed using typesafe Java 8 lambda expressions rather than the Spring-EL expression. Note that the transformation expression could have coded in quite few alternate ways: ??.transform((String s) -> s.toUpperCase()) Or: ??.transform(s -> s.toUpperCase()) Or using method references: ??.transform(String::toUpperCase) Moving onto the more complicated Rube Goldberg flow to accomplish the same task, again starting with XML based configuration. There are two configurations to express this flow: rube-1.xml: This configuration takes care of steps 1, 2, 3, 6, 7, 8 : It takes in a message of this type - "hello from spring integ" splits it up into individual words(hello, from, spring, integ) sends each word to a ActiveMQ queue from the queue the word fragments are picked up by a enricher to capitalize each word placing the response back into a response queue It is picked up, resequenced based on the original sequence of the words aggregated back into a sentence("HELLO FROM SPRING INTEG") and returned back to the application. and rube-2.xml for steps 4, 5: It takes in a message of this type - "hello from spring integ" splits it up into individual words(hello, from, spring, integ) sends each word to a ActiveMQ queue from the queue the word fragments are picked up by a enricher to capitalize each word placing the response back into a response queue It is picked up, resequenced based on the original sequence of the words aggregated back into a sentence("HELLO FROM SPRING INTEG") and returned back to the application. Now, expressing this Rube Goldberg flow using Spring Integration Java DSL, the configuration looks like this, again in two parts: EchoFlowOutbound.java: @Bean public DirectChannel sequenceChannel() { return new DirectChannel(); } @Bean public DirectChannel requestChannel() { return new DirectChannel(); } @Bean public IntegrationFlow toOutboundQueueFlow() { return IntegrationFlows.from(requestChannel()) .split(s -> s.applySequence(true).get().getT2().setDelimiters("\\s")) .handle(jmsOutboundGateway()) .get(); } @Bean public IntegrationFlow flowOnReturnOfMessage() { return IntegrationFlows.from(sequenceChannel()) .resequence() .aggregate(aggregate -> aggregate.outputProcessor(g -> Joiner.on(" ").join(g.getMessages() .stream() .map(m -> (String) m.getPayload()).collect(toList()))) , null) .get(); } and EchoFlowInbound.java: @Bean public JmsMessageDrivenEndpoint jmsInbound() { return new JmsMessageDrivenEndpoint(listenerContainer(), messageListener()); } @Bean public IntegrationFlow inboundFlow() { return IntegrationFlows.from(enhanceMessageChannel()) .transform((String s) -> s.toUpperCase()) .get(); } Again here the code is completely typesafe and is checked for any errors at development time rather than at runtime as with the XML based configuration. Again I like the fact that transformation, aggregation statements can be expressed concisely using Java 8 lamda expressions as opposed to Spring-EL expressions. What I have not displayed here is some of the support code, to set up the activemq test infrastructure, this configuration continues to remain as xml and I have included this code in a sample github project. All in all, I am very excited to see this new way of expressing the Spring Integration messaging flow using pure Java and I am looking forward to seeing its continuing evolution and may be even try and participate in its evolution in small ways. Here is the entire working code in a github repo: https://github.com/bijukunjummen/rg-si References and Acknowledgement: Spring Integration Java DSL introduction blog article by Artem Bilan: https://spring.io/blog/2014/05/08/spring-integration-java-dsl-milestone-1-released Spring Integration Java DSL website and wiki: https://github.com/spring-projects/spring-integration-extensions/wiki/Spring-Integration-Java-DSL-Reference. A lot of code has been shamelessly copied over from this wiki by me :-). Also, a big thanks to Artem for guidance on a question that I had Webinar by Gary Russell on Spring Integration 4.0 in which Spring Integration Java DSL is covered in great detail.
June 3, 2014
by Biju Kunjummen
· 43,978 Views
article thumbnail
Understanding how Parquet Integrates with Avro, Thrift and Protocol Buffers
parquet is a new columnar storage format that come out of a collaboration between twitter and cloudera. parquet’s generating a lot of excitement in the community for good reason - it’s shaping up to be the next big thing for data storage in hadoop for a number of reasons: it’s a sophisticated columnar file format, which means that it’s well-suited to olap workloads, or really any workload where projection is a normal part of working with the data. it has a high level of integration with hadoop and the ecosystem - you can work with parquet in mapreduce, pig, hive and impala. it supports avro, thrift and protocol buffers. the last item raises a question - how does parquet work with avro and friends? to understand this you’ll need to understand three concepts: storage formats , which are binary representations of data. for parquet this is contained within the parquet-format github project. object model converters , whose job it is to map between an external object model and parquet’s internal data types. these converters exist in the parquet-mr github project. object models , which are in-memory representations of data. avro , thrift , protocol buffers , hive and pig are all examples of object models. parquet does actually supply an example object model (with mapreduce support ) , but the intention is that you’d use one of the other richer object models such as avro. the figure below shows a visual representation of these concepts ( view a larger image ). avro, thrift and protocol buffers all have have their own storage formats, but parquet doesn’t utilize them in any way. instead their objects are mapped to the parquet data model. parquet data is always serialized using its own file format. this is why parquet can’t read files serialized using avro’s storage format, and vice-versa. let’s examine what happens when you write an avro object to parquet: the avro converter stores within the parquet file’s metadata the schema for the objects being written. you can see this by using a parquet cli to dumps out the parquet metadata contained within a parquet file. $ export hadoop_classpath=parquet-avro-1.4.3.jar:parquet-column-1.4.3.jar:parquet-common-1.4.3.jar:parquet-encoding-1.4.3.jar:parquet-format-2.0.0.jar:parquet-generator-1.4.3.jar:parquet-hadoop-1.4.3.jar:parquet-hive-bundle-1.4.3.jar:parquet-jackson-1.4.3.jar:parquet-tools-1.4.3.jar $ hadoop parquet.tools.main meta stocks.parquet creator: parquet-mr (build 3f25ad97f209e7653e9f816508252f850abd635f) extra: avro.schema = {"type":"record","name":"stock","namespace" [more]... file schema: hip.ch5.avro.gen.stock -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- symbol: required binary o:utf8 r:0 d:0 date: required binary o:utf8 r:0 d:0 open: required double r:0 d:0 high: required double r:0 d:0 low: required double r:0 d:0 close: required double r:0 d:0 volume: required int32 r:0 d:0 adjclose: required double r:0 d:0 row group 1: rc:45 ts:2376 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- symbol: binary uncompressed do:0 fpo:4 sz:84/84/1.00 vc:45 enc:b [more]... date: binary uncompressed do:0 fpo:88 sz:198/198/1.00 vc:45 en [more]... open: double uncompressed do:0 fpo:286 sz:379/379/1.00 vc:45 e [more]... high: double uncompressed do:0 fpo:665 sz:379/379/1.00 vc:45 e [more]... low: double uncompressed do:0 fpo:1044 sz:379/379/1.00 vc:45 [more]... close: double uncompressed do:0 fpo:1423 sz:379/379/1.00 vc:45 [more]... volume: int32 uncompressed do:0 fpo:1802 sz:199/199/1.00 vc:45 e [more]... adjclose: double uncompressed do:0 fpo:2001 sz:379/379/1.00 vc:45 [more]... the “avro.schema” is where the avro schema information is stored. this allows the avro parquet reader the ability to marshall avro objects without the client having to supply the schema. you can also use the “schema” command to view the parquet schema. $ hadoop parquet.tools.main schema stocks.parquet message hip.ch4.avro.gen.stock { required binary symbol (utf8); required binary date (utf8); required double open; required double high; required double low; required double close; required int32 volume; required double adjclose; } this tool is useful when loading a parquet file into hive, as you’ll need to use the field names defined in the parquet schema when defining the hive table (note that the syntax below only works with hive 0.13 and newer). hive> create external table parquet_stocks( symbol string, date string, open double, high double, low double, close double, volume int, adjclose double ) stored as parquet location '...';
June 1, 2014
by Alex Holmes
· 48,989 Views · 30 Likes
article thumbnail
Implementing Correlation ids in Spring Boot (for Distributed Tracing in SOA/Microservices)
After attending Sam Newman’s microservice talks at Geecon last week I started to think more about what is most likely an essential feature of service-oriented/microservice platforms for monitoring, reporting and diagnostics: correlation ids. Correlation ids allow distributed tracing within complex service oriented platforms, where a single request into the application can often be dealt with by multiple downstream service. Without the ability to correlate downstream service requests it can be very difficult to understand how requests are being handled within your platform. I’ve seen the benefit of correlation ids in several recent SOA projects I have worked on, but as Sam mentioned in his talks, it’s often very easy to think this type of tracing won’t be needed when building the initial version of the application, but then very difficult to retrofit into the application when you do realise the benefits (and the need for!). I’ve not yet found the perfect way to implement correlation ids within a Java/Spring-based application, but after chatting to Sam via email he made several suggestions which I have now turned into a simple project using Spring Boot to demonstrate how this could be implemented. Why? During both of Sam’s Geecon talks he mentioned that in his experience correlation ids were very useful for diagnostic purposes. Correlation ids are essentially an id that is generated and associated with a single (typically user-driven) request into the application that is passed down through the stack and onto dependent services. In SOA or microservice platforms this type of id is very useful, as requests into the application typically are ‘fanned out’ or handled by multiple downstream services, and a correlation id allows all of the downstream requests (from the initial point of request) to be correlated or grouped based on the id. So called ‘distributed tracing’ can then be performed using the correlation ids by combining all the downstream service logs and matching the required id to see the trace of the request throughout your entire application stack (which is very easy if you are using a centralised logging framework such as logstash) The big players in the service-oriented field have been talking about the need for distributed tracing and correlating requests for quite some time, and as such Twitter have created their open source Zipkin framework (which often plugs into their RPC framework Finagle), and Netflix has open-sourced their Karyon web/microservice framework, both of which provide distributed tracing. There are of course commercial offering in this area, one such product being AppDynamics, which is very cool, but has a rather hefty price tag. Creating a proof-of-concept in Spring Boot As great as Zipkin and Karyon are, they are both relatively invasive, in that you have to build your services on top of the (often opinionated) frameworks. This might be fine for some use cases, but no so much for others, especially when you are building microservices. I’ve been enjoying experimenting with Spring Boot of late, and this framework builds on the much known and loved (at least by me :-) ) Spring framework by providing lots of preconfigured sensible defaults. This allows you to build microservices (especially ones that communicate via RESTful interfaces) very rapidly. The remainder of this blog pos explains how I implemented a (hopefully) non-invasive way of implementing correlation ids. Goals Allow a correlation id to be generated for a initial request into the application Enable the correlation id to be passed to downstream services, using as method that is as non-invasive into the code as possible Implementation I have created two projects on GitHub, one containing an implementation where all requests are being handled in a synchronous style (i.e. the traditional Spring approach of handling all request processing on a single thread), and also one for when an asynchronous (non-blocking) style of communication is being used (i.e., using the Servlet 3 asynchronous support combined with Spring’s DeferredResult and Java’s Futures/Callables). The majority of this article describes the asynchronous implementation, as this is more interesting: Spring Boot asynchronous (DeferredResult + Futures) communication correlation id Github repo The main work in both code bases is undertaken by the CorrelationHeaderFilter, which is a standard Java EE Filter that inspects the HttpServletRequest header for the presence of a correlationId. If one is found then we set a ThreadLocal variable in the RequestCorrelation Class (discussed later). If a correlation id is not found then one is generated and added to the RequestCorrelation Class: public class CorrelationHeaderFilter implements Filter { //... @Override public void doFilter(ServletRequest servletRequest, ServletResponse servletResponse, FilterChain filterChain) throws IOException, ServletException { final HttpServletRequest httpServletRequest = (HttpServletRequest) servletRequest; String currentCorrId = httpServletRequest.getHeader(RequestCorrelation.CORRELATION_ID_HEADER); if (!currentRequestIsAsyncDispatcher(httpServletRequest)) { if (currentCorrId == null) { currentCorrId = UUID.randomUUID().toString(); LOGGER.info("No correlationId found in Header. Generated : " + currentCorrId); } else { LOGGER.info("Found correlationId in Header : " + currentCorrId); } RequestCorrelation.setId(currentCorrId); } filterChain.doFilter(httpServletRequest, servletResponse); } //... private boolean currentRequestIsAsyncDispatcher(HttpServletRequest httpServletRequest) { return httpServletRequest.getDispatcherType().equals(DispatcherType.ASYNC); } The only thing is this code that may not instantly be obvious is the conditional checkcurrentRequestIsAsyncDispatcher(httpServletRequest), but this is here to guard against the correlation id code being executed when the Async Dispatcher thread is running to return the results (this is interesting to note, as I initially didn’t expect the Async Dispatcher to trigger the execution of the filter again?) Here is the RequestCorrelation Class, which contains a simple ThreadLocal static variable to hold the correlation id for the current Thread of execution (set via the CorrelationHeaderFilter above) public class RequestCorrelation { public static final String CORRELATION_ID = "correlationId"; private static final ThreadLocal id = new ThreadLocal(); public static String getId() { return id.get(); } public static void setId(String correlationId) { id.set(correlationId); } } Once the correlation id is stored in the RequestCorrelation Class it can be retrieved and added to downstream service requests (or data store access etc) as required by calling the static getId() method within RequestCorrelation. It is probably a good idea to encapsulate this behaviour away from your application services, and you can see an example of how to do this in a RestClient Class I have created, which composes Spring’s RestTemplate and handles the setting of the correlation id within the header transparently from the calling Class. @Component public class CorrelatingRestClient implements RestClient { private RestTemplate restTemplate = new RestTemplate(); @Override public String getForString(String uri) { String correlationId = RequestCorrelation.getId(); HttpHeaders httpHeaders = new HttpHeaders(); httpHeaders.set(RequestCorrelation.CORRELATION_ID, correlationId); LOGGER.info("start REST request to {} with correlationId {}", uri, correlationId); //TODO: error-handling and fault-tolerance in production ResponseEntity response = restTemplate.exchange(uri, HttpMethod.GET, new HttpEntity(httpHeaders), String.class); LOGGER.info("completed REST request to {} with correlationId {}", uri, correlationId); return response.getBody(); } } //... calling Class public String exampleMethod() { RestClient restClient = new CorrelatingRestClient(); return restClient.getForString(URI_LOCATION); //correlation id handling completely abstracted to RestClient impl } Making this work for asynchronous requests… The code included above works fine when you are handling all of your requests synchronously, but it is often a good idea in a SOA/microservice platform to handle requests in a non-blocking asynchronous manner. In Spring this can be achieved by using the DeferredResult Class in combination with the Servlet 3 asynchronous support. The problem with using ThreadLocal variables within the asynchronous approach is that the Thread that initially handles the request (and creates the DeferredResult/Future) will not be the Thread doing the actual processing. Accordingly, a bit of glue code is needed to ensure that the correlation id is propagated across the Threads. This can be achieved by extending Callable with the required functionality: (don’t worry if example Calling Class code doesn’t look intuitive – this adaption between DeferredResults and Futures is a necessary evil within Spring, and the full code including the boilerplate ListenableFutureAdapter is in my GitHub repo): public class CorrelationCallable implements Callable { private String correlationId; private Callable callable; public CorrelationCallable(Callable targetCallable) { correlationId = RequestCorrelation.getId(); callable = targetCallable; } @Override public V call() throws Exception { RequestCorrelation.setId(correlationId); return callable.call(); } } //... Calling Class @RequestMapping("externalNews") public DeferredResult externalNews() { return new ListenableFutureAdapter<>(service.submit(new CorrelationCallable<>(externalNewsService::getNews))); } And there we have it – the propagation of correlation id regardless of the synchronous/asynchronous nature of processing! You can clone the Github report containing my asynchronous example, and execute the application by running mvn spring-boot:run at the command line. If you access http://localhost:8080/externalNewsin your browser (or via curl) you will see something similar to the following in your Spring Boot console, which clearly demonstrates a correlation id being generated on the initial request, and then this being propagated through to a simulated external call (have a look in the ExternalNewsServiceRest Class to see how this has been implemented): [nio-8080-exec-1] u.c.t.e.c.w.f.CorrelationHeaderFilter : No correlationId found in Header. Generated : d205991b-c613-4acd-97b8-97112b2b2ad0 [pool-1-thread-1] u.c.t.e.c.w.c.CorrelatingRestClient : start REST request to http://localhost:8080/news with correlationId d205991b-c613-4acd-97b8-97112b2b2ad0 [nio-8080-exec-2] u.c.t.e.c.w.f.CorrelationHeaderFilter : Found correlationId in Header : d205991b-c613-4acd-97b8-97112b2b2ad0 [pool-1-thread-1] u.c.t.e.c.w.c.CorrelatingRestClient : completed REST request to http://localhost:8080/news with correlationId d205991b-c613-4acd-97b8-97112b2b2ad0 Conclusion I’m quite happy with this simple prototype, and it does meet the two goals I listed above. Future work will include writing some tests for this code (shame on me for not TDDing!), and also extend this functionality to a more realistic example. I would like to say a massive thanks to Sam, not only for sharing his knowledge at the great talks at Geecon, but also for taking time to respond to my emails. If you’re interested in microservices and related work I can highly recommend Sam’s Microservice book which is available in Early Access at O’Reilly. I’ve enjoyed reading the currently available chapters, and having implemented quite a few SOA projects recently I can relate to a lot of the good advice contained within. I’ll be following the development of this book with keen interest! If you have any comments or thoughts then please do share them via the comment below, or feel free to get in touch via the usual mechanisms! References I used Tomasz Nurkiewicz’s excellent blog several times for learning how best to wire up all of the DeferredResult/Future code in Spring: http://www.nurkiewicz.com/2013/03/deferredresult-asynchronous-processing.html
May 29, 2014
by Daniel Bryant
· 24,607 Views · 1 Like
  • Previous
  • ...
  • 727
  • 728
  • 729
  • 730
  • 731
  • 732
  • 733
  • 734
  • 735
  • 736
  • ...
  • Next
  • RSS
  • X
  • Facebook

ABOUT US

  • About DZone
  • Support and feedback
  • Community research

ADVERTISE

  • Advertise with DZone

CONTRIBUTE ON DZONE

  • Article Submission Guidelines
  • Become a Contributor
  • Core Program
  • Visit the Writers' Zone

LEGAL

  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy

CONTACT US

  • 3343 Perimeter Hill Drive
  • Suite 215
  • Nashville, TN 37211
  • [email protected]

Let's be friends:

  • RSS
  • X
  • Facebook
×